Eugenia Tymoshenko Carr, daughter of ex-Prime Minister Yulia Tymoshenko. Eugenia Tymoshenko asks Americans 'to speak out, loudly and clearly' for human rights in Ukraine Yesterday at 22:44 | Eugenia CarrEditor's Note: The following is testimony before the U.S. Senate Foreign Relations Committee in Washington, D.C., by Eugenia Tymoshenko Carr, daughter of imprisoned ex-Prime Minister Yulia Tymoshenko.
Testimony
Eugenia Tymoshenko Carr
Before the Senate Foreign Relations Committee
Ukraine at a Crossroads: What's at Stake for the U.S. and Europe?
Wednesday, February 1, 2012
Written Statement
Thank you Senator [Jeanne] Shaheen. Thank you for granting me, a citizen of Ukraine, the privilege
of coming here to speak to the Senate and through you, to the people of the United States. It
is such an honor for me to be in this hallowed place, but I know that you are truly honoring
my country and my mother by inviting me here to discuss with you this moment of grave
danger for Ukraine’s liberty, and our independence as a nation.
I am very glad to see that you are from New Hampshire, Senator Shaheen. My mother has
always admired your state motto: “Live Free or Die.”
I hardly know where to begin in discussing what is happening in Ukraine, given the daily
threats to what is left of our democracy. Perhaps I ought to begin with the sad and amazing
words taken from the internet petition to free my mother, filed by Bishop Paul Peter Jesep,
where he quoted the French thinker Montesquieu, and it says, “There is no greater tyranny,
than that which is perpetrated under the shield of law and in the name of justice.”
My mother has been illegally imprisoned, maltreated and humiliated for six months by the
regime which is trying to break her. This didn’t break her. Her spirits are high, I can say that
emphatically, but her health is failing. When I see her I must lift her from her bed; she can
barely walk. Yet she still works, and not only to fight all the legal mud that is being thrown
at her, but to unify all of Ukraine’s democratic forces to challenge President Viktor
Yanukovych and the repressive clan that rules with him.
My mother went into politics and put on her small shoulders the great task to free her country
of injustice, absence of rule of law and corruption left from Soviet past, so that we, young
Ukrainians, would not need to devote our lives to do the same. She, unlike many young
entrepreneurs in newly independent Ukraine, managed to build a big, successful corporation
that helped restore the lost production and trade ties between ex-Soviet states. By doing that
she uncovered most major failures of the old system. One of the major failures was and now
remains – corruption. She chose to go against the system, refused to be part of corrupt
schemes and, ended up facing the system alone, letting it destroy her business, putting her,
her family and friends behind bars and again on falsified charges.
Ten years ago, when my mother was Vice Prime Minister for the Energy Sector, she
managed to remove corruption in oil, electricity and gas trading and restored financial
functioning in this sector. When the country’s leadership resisted her reform efforts she
organized massive protest movements. These protests later grew into the Orange revolution,
which she helped to lead and supported a person for president she believed would lead the
country into democratic victory.
While Prime Minister even though she had limited control but big responsibilities, she fought
for major reforms and country’s well-being. After she had removed the gas trading
monopolist RosUkrEnergo she became enemy number one, to those who were trying to
monopolize the energy market and who are in power now. She ended up illegally imprisoned,
convicted and tortured for not playing by the rules of their game, not complying with their
orders that were detrimental to Ukraine.
Her cell in Kachanivska prison outside of Kharkiv, far from her family and friends, is not a
dungeon you may be relieved to know. But the Yanukovych regime does not need to use
medieval surroundings to get medieval results. Instead, they are using the modern techniques
of sleep deprivation and intimidation to try and break her. They won’t succeed. They are able
to deny her a restful night’s sleep because her cell is kept lit and she is filmed and watched 24
hours a day. Lately, they have introduced a close up surveillance camera so that they can see
what she is writing to me, to her husband, to her supporters and to the world.
They say it is done for her protection but I doubt it. When she fell unconscious in her cell due
to a sudden mysterious loss of blood pressure, no help came, as her cellmate waited for 20
long minutes for a doctor to come in, who didn’t even call an ambulance. She could’ve died
that night. We found out about the incident three days later from her and her cellmate. Later,
they would “lose” the video archive and would make her cellmate re-write her witness
statement.
You will not be surprised to learn that since her incarceration and the constant pressure the
regime has placed on her, my mother has developed serious health problems, which have
gone untreated. The regime will say that this is my mother’s own choice. But can anyone
seriously expect her to trust her physical well-being to a regime that directs doctors to falsify
their diagnoses. Her only request is to be examined by her own doctors, or independent
doctors from abroad. That does not seem unreasonable. People who keep her behind bars
say: “of course, yes, yes”, then nothing happens. But no one should be surprised by that. As
European leaders have learned all too well over the past year, Yanukovych can’t be trusted to
keep his word.
The intimidation that my mother is enduring comes from the fact that the regime and its
prosecutorial henchmen keep piling criminal charge upon criminal charge, so that my mother
and her small team of lawyers are simply overwhelmed. Against all legal norms, she is
interrogated in her cell, sometimes for 12 or more hours consecutively. She is given
inadequate time to review the documents that will be used against her in the next court
hearing. It was clear at the first trial and at the appeal court that my mother was convicted
before the evidence was heard. She was even denied a closing statement and evidence that
would have proven her innocence was not admitted. Over 100 other motions made by the
defence team were denied.
I have no doubts that the verdict against my mother was sought and approved by President
Yanukovych. She is, according to recent polls, his main political opponent and more popular
than him.
But I don’t want you to think that this is only about my mother. It is not. Others are being
repressed and unjustly imprisoned.
Her former colleague, Minister of Interior Yuri Lutsenko has been imprisoned for over a year
on charges that would be laughable if they were not so tragic. He is charged with hiring a
driver past the retirement age and of spending $2000.00 over budget to mark Ukraine’s
national police day. I don’t know American political practice very well, but I can’t imagine a
former cabinet minister be jailed for over a year without trial on such charges.
And there are others. The son-in-law of a Supreme Court Chairman was arrested on the day
his wife gave birth, in order to intimidate that justice into resigning. Former Acting Minister
of Defence Valery Ivashchenko has been imprisoned for almost two years, with his health
severely deteriorating. They are all repressed and humiliated because of their political views.
They courageously stood up to the regime and the injustice and fear it is sowing.
Unfortunately Ukraine turns into an authoritarian regime with leaders of the opposition sitting
in jail.
What we are witnessing in Ukraine is the continuous abuse of the criminal justice system.
Politically motivated prosecutions of former government officials, civil society activists and
prosecutions of human rights defenders ignore the rule of law. I believe that the current
situation, as described in the recent European Parliament and Parliamentary Assembly of the
Council of Europe resolutions, requires urgent action.
To say that prosecution of the opposition is just a problem of the outdated legislation is to
miss the obvious. It's really not so much the law at fault but how it is enforced. Ukrainian
authorities cynically blame the law while everyone knows that the prosecution system and the
judiciary is under the complete control of the governing party via the so called High Council
of Justice, which is controlled by President Yanukovych. No law enforcement agency dares
to make a move to prosecute the political opposition without instruction from the President.
Numerous legal infringements of the European Convention of Human Rights were listed and
explained in three reports of the Danish Helsinki Committee, which was commissioned by
the EU, to find the truth in the political, so-called “criminal” cases. This shows a systematic
prosecution of the opposition or people close to it. And my mother is the main target.
What we are witnessing in Ukraine is such a twisting of the rule of law that it is impossible to
distinguish illegality from legality, hard to see the line between law and abuse of law. My
mother is imprisoned under an old Soviet Era Criminal code of 1960, that criminalizes
political decisions. Even as out-dated as they are, they have been applied illegally in her case.
It is important to know that there was no accusation or evidence introduced in the court that
my mother personally gained from negotiating the gas deals and ending the European gas
crisis in January 2009. Two letters filed by acting Minister of Justice, Mr. Lavrynovich and
ex-Prosecutor General, Mr. Medvedko, state the same. The state gas trading company
“Naftogas” has recently issued a statement, that calculation of losses that my mother is
charged with, was done under severe pressure from the General Prosecutor’s Office.
Politically motivated charges of which my mother was found innocent a decade ago have also
been reopened, with no legal basis. Past Supreme Court rulings are being ignored. The
statute of limitations is also ignored, as some of the charges now being brought against my
mother for her business activities stem from 15 and 16 years ago. They have been re-opened
for only one reason, to destroy her reputation in the EU and the USA.
These new cases can take care of a few other problems for Yanukovych’s government. She
will stay in jail despite the European Court of Human Rights’ decision, if it is in her favour.
They put more psychological pressure on her by prosecuting and charging her husband, her
father-in-law and ex-colleagues.
Yanukovych and his team are trying to do everything possible to charge my mother with
corruption. They hope the smallest hint of corruption will confuse Western politicians and
make them turn their back on Ukraine and on her. And that’s what Yanukovych’s
administration is trying to achieve. They spent millions of US dollars hiring American audit
companies in hoping they can find traces of her corruption. Hundreds of her ex-co-workers
were summoned for questioning. They were looking hard, but never found anything and they
never will.
The current government’s activities are not only ruining the image of Ukraine, and Ukraine
as a united nation, but also the profitable sectors of the economy, that become paralyzed and
eventually abandoned, when the rule of law is ignored. Successful people prefer to leave
Ukraine and our population is declining.
Indeed, not even our constitution has survived Yanukovych’s contempt for law. To grab
more power for himself, he simply junked it. His first breach of the Constitution, was signing
a shameful Kharkov agreement with Russia which was nothing but a concession of Ukraine’s
national interests. The lease of Sevastopol naval base to Russia was supposed to give Ukraine
a major discount on Russian natural gas, but at the end of the day Yanukovych got a price
$100 higher than my mother did in 2009. By this standard, he and not my mother should be in
prison if the law was applied equally.
I know that Ukraine must seem like a faraway place, and that our problems must also seem
distant from the concerns of Americans at this difficult time for America. But just as no man
is an island unto himself, no democracy is an island. When one nation’s is allowed to be
hijacked, all democracies are threatened. Ukraine exists in a fragile neighbourhood, where
war broke out just a few years ago across the Black Sea in Georgia.
I am here today to answer your questions, Senator Shaheen, but also to plead that America do
all that it can to preserve democracy in my country. My mother’s plight has united many
great, strong nations and amazing people, true heroes of our time who are trying to get her
and other political prisoners out of jail. We are hoping for your support. It is paramount for
Ukraine to have free and fair elections this fall, but it would be impossible without major
opposition leaders.
I know my mother will not let Ukraine fall back into the Soviet past. She is strong enough to
do it and to win the elections if she is allowed to run. She has already succeeded in bringing
fractioned opposition into one united front.
The enemies of democracy and freedom should not be welcome in a democratic society
unless they correct their mistakes. I ask you to consider all possible ways to influence them
and to explain to them the consequences of their actions. But most of all, I ask you to speak
out, loudly and clearly, so that the people of my country do not feel abandoned and lose hope.
See the original post:
Eugenia Tymoshenko asks Americans 'to speak out, loudly and clearly' for human rights in Ukraine