On November 22, 2020, Judge Howard C. Nielson, Jr. of the United States District Court for the District of Utah dismissed with prejudice a putative class action asserting claims under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 against a biotechnology company and certain of its executives. In re PolarityTE, Inc. Sec. Litig., No. 2:18-cv-00510, 2020 WL 6873798 (D. Utah Nov. 22, 2020). Plaintiffs alleged that the company made material misstatements in the course of a reverse merger and in subsequent SEC filings. The Court held that plaintiffs failed to adequately allege falsity with respect to certain challenged statements and failed to establish loss causation for the remainder.
Plaintiffs alleged that the company made misstatements concerning: (1) the companys registration of a product with the FDA under a particular provision of the Public Health Service Act, which the company ultimately abandoned and refiled under a different provision after the FDA disagreed with the companys original approach, id. at *3-4; (2) the quality of the companys manufacturing facilities, in light of violations reported by the FDA, id. at *4; (3) the companys patents, including with respect to an application for which the company had received a non-final rejection a week before the merger closed and subsequently received a final rejection, id. at *2; and (4) the non-existence of any pending or contemplated government proceedings against the company, in light of the company having received a document request from the SEC after reporting to the SEC suspicious trading of its stock. Id. at *5.
The Court first assessed the companys statements regarding its products registration with the FDA and concluded that plaintiffs likely failed to allege a material misstatement, id. at *8, because the challenged statements were either true (to the extent they preceded the companys announcement that it intended to proceed under a different regulatory scheme) or constituted statements of opinion as to whether it was appropriate to pursue registration under the framework originally chosen by the company. Id. at *8. The Court further stated that plaintiffs likely fail[ed] to allege that the company lacked any factual basis for its opinions, thus rendering the opinions nonactionable. Id.
The Court did not, however, definitively determine whether a material misrepresentation had been alleged with regard to the registration issues, relying instead on its conclusion that plaintiffs failed to allege loss causation because the purported corrective disclosures (articles published regarding the company) relied on information previously disclosed to the market. Id. at *9. While noting that the Tenth Circuit had not squarely addressed the issue, the Court observed that other Circuits have held that, to qualify as a corrective disclosure, the disclosure must reveal non-public information. Id. at *6. Here, however, the articles plaintiffs relied upon did not actually reveal any then-undisclosed facts; instead, all the materials the articles referenced were publicly available. Id. at *9. Furthermore, the Court explained that, although some courts have ruled that expert analysis of publicly available information could constitute a corrective disclosure, there was no indication that the authors of the articles relied upon by plaintiffs had any expertise beyond that of careful investors. Id.
The Court next assessed plaintiffs allegations that the companys statements concerning the quality of its manufacturing facilities were materially misleading because the FDA had reported violations in July 2018. Id. at *10. The Court concluded that the challenged statements were either puffery or, in any event, plaintiffs failed to allege how the statements were rendered false by the FDAs findings. Id. While noting that the company had received the FDAs report before the challenged statements were made, the Court emphasized that the FDA had not made a final determination at the time, and that ultimately the FDA closed the inspection indicating that the allegedly objectionable conditions [did] not meet the threshold of regulatory significance. Id. Furthermore, the Court noted that two months passed between the FDAs inspection and the statements in question, during which time it appear[ed] that [the company] had made at least some improvements to its processes in response to the FDAs concerns. Id. at *11. In light of those circumstances, the Court concluded that the FDAs report does not support a reasonable inference that the individual who made the statements did not believe the puffing statements of corporate optimism. Id. at *11.
Turning to statements concerning the companys patents, the Court first noted that statements by the company that its products were subject to pending patent applications were true. Id. To the extent the company erroneously described certain technology as patented, the Court reasoned that those statements were immaterial because other company statements made clear that the technology at issue was not presently protected by existing patents but was rather the subject of pending patent applications. Id. The Court reasoned that, to the extent these statements were conflicting, that would have given a reasonable investor sufficient pause to warrant independent verification. Id. at *12. While the Court thus concluded that plaintiffs likely failed to adequately allege a material misstatement, id. at *11, it held that, regardless, plaintiffs again failed to adequately allege loss causation because the articles relied on as corrective disclosures were based on previously available information. Id. at *12.
Finally, the Court rejected plaintiffs argument that the companys statements about not being subject to any pending or contemplated governmental proceedings were false because the company had received a document request from the SEC. Id. at *13. The Court concluded that an isolated document request is not an investigation, and, in context, it was not reasonable to believe the company should have expected the SEC to conduct an investigation based on the request received. Id. The Court also observed that, even if an investigation had been contemplated, the companys statement was not false because [a]n investigation on its own is not a pending legal proceeding, and the SEC had not informed the company that it was contemplating further action. Id.
Because plaintiffs had not filed a motion seeking leave to amend, the Court dismissed the action with prejudice. Id.
Links & Downloads -
In re PolarityTE, Inc. Sec. Litig.
[View source.]
Read the rest here:
Utah District Court Dismisses Putative Securities Class Action Against Biotechnology Firm For Failure To Allege Falsity And Loss Causation - JD Supra
- U.S. Biotechnology Market Size to Increase USD 1.79 Trillion by 2033 - BioSpace - April 16th, 2024
- 6 biotechnology universities in the USA developing young talent - Labiotech.eu - April 16th, 2024
- Lee Hsien Loong presided over efforts to retool Singapore's export-driven economy by focusing on advanced ... - NBC Right Now - April 16th, 2024
- UNITY Biotechnology, Inc. Reports Fourth Quarter and Full Year 2023 Financial Results and Business Updates - GlobeNewswire - April 16th, 2024
- Lee Hsien Loong presided over efforts to retool Singapore's export-driven economy by focusing on advanced ... - pdclarion.com - April 16th, 2024
- BIO's top lobbyist heads out the door - FiercePharma - April 16th, 2024
- BIO's top lobbyist exits, signaling reorganization - STAT - STAT - April 16th, 2024
- Biotech Rebound Could Boost This ETF - ETF Trends - April 16th, 2024
- US National Security, China and Biotechnology in 2024 - BioSpace - April 8th, 2024
- How to Invest in Biotechnology (Updated 2024) - Nasdaq - April 8th, 2024
- Self-pigmenting textiles grown from cellulose-producing bacteria with engineered tyrosinase expression - Nature.com - April 8th, 2024
- Genetically encoding colors and images into bioengineered microbial materials - Nature.com - April 8th, 2024
- Ambition and urgency: Biotechnology and Biomanufacturing in the EU - EURACTIV - April 8th, 2024
- Scientists create plastic-free vegan leather that dyes itself, grown from bacteria - Phys.org - April 8th, 2024
- For national security, the U.S. must maintain its biotech dominance - STAT - April 8th, 2024
- LLY, REGN, BHVN: Which Biotech Stock Offers the Most Upside? - Yahoo Finance - April 8th, 2024
- Is biotechnology a good career? Here are the pros and cons - Labiotech.eu - March 18th, 2024
- Saving Biology With Blue Biotechnology - The Maritime Executive - March 18th, 2024
- 30 Biggest Biotechnology Companies in the World - Yahoo Finance - March 18th, 2024
- WuXi out of biotech trade group, U.S. and China relations to blame - STAT - March 18th, 2024
- Can Biotechnology Save the Fashion Industry? - EARTH.ORG - March 18th, 2024
- Huber high-precision temperature control solutions for the pharmaceutical industry and biotechnology - Labmate Online - March 18th, 2024
- The twelve hottest biotech companies in the Boston area - Labiotech.eu - March 18th, 2024
- Vancouver readies for its position as a global pharma capital as B.C.'s biotech boom takes off - The Globe and Mail - March 10th, 2024
- Here's Why We're A Bit Worried About Unity Biotechnology's (NASDAQ:UBX) Cash Burn Situation - Simply Wall St - March 10th, 2024
- The Top 25 Biotechnology Companies of 2024 - The Healthcare Technology Report. - March 10th, 2024
- Near-cognate tRNAs increase the efficiency and precision of pseudouridine-mediated readthrough of premature ... - Nature.com - March 10th, 2024
- MAIA Biotechnology and Nationwide Children's Hospital Announce Presentation of THIO's Potency in Pediatric Brain ... - Business Wire - March 10th, 2024
- Global Pharmaceuticals and Biotechnology Distribution Deals Analysis Report and Directory 2024: Breakdown of ... - PR Newswire - March 10th, 2024
- Pharmaceuticals and Biotechnology Co-promotion and Co-marketing Partnering Trends Report 2024: Analysis of ... - PR Newswire - March 10th, 2024
- INTERNATIONAL BIOTECHNOLOGY TRUST has a healthy attitude towards paying investors - This is Money - March 10th, 2024
- Where Does Capricor Therapeutics Inc (CAPR) Stock Fall in the Biotechnology Field After It Has Risen 24.73% This Week? - InvestorsObserver - March 10th, 2024
- Biotechnology should be high on the agenda at the Munich Security Conference - The Hill - February 18th, 2024
- Boston is best in the world at biotech. Beijing wants to do it better - WBUR News - February 18th, 2024
- Multiomics Are The Next Step In Biotechnology - Securities.io - February 18th, 2024
- SPARKing academic technologies across the valley of death - Nature.com - February 18th, 2024
- Is Nurix Therapeutics Inc (NRIX) Stock at the Top of the Biotechnology Industry? - InvestorsObserver - February 18th, 2024
- Addressing the Threat to U.S. Biotechnology: Concerns Over Genetic Data Security - Medriva - February 18th, 2024
- Where Does SpringWorks Therapeutics Inc (SWTX) Stock Fall in the Biotechnology Field After It Has Gained 12.41% This Week? - InvestorsObserver - February 18th, 2024
- Should Biotechnology Stock Axsome Therapeutics Inc (AXSM) Be in Your Portfolio Wednesday? - InvestorsObserver - February 18th, 2024
- Where Does Candel Therapeutics Inc (CADL) Stock Fall in the Biotechnology Field After It Has Gained 22.38% This Week? - InvestorsObserver - February 18th, 2024
- Is Tempest Therapeutics Inc (TPST) a Leader in the Biotechnology Industry? - InvestorsObserver - February 18th, 2024
- Is Immunome Inc (IMNM) a Good Buy in the Biotechnology Industry? - InvestorsObserver - February 18th, 2024
- Is Larimar Therapeutics Inc (LRMR) a Leader in the Biotechnology Industry? - InvestorsObserver - February 18th, 2024
- US lawmakers, visiting Cambridge, warn of a rising Chinese threat to US biotech - The Boston Globe - February 18th, 2024
- Should Biotechnology Stock Viking Therapeutics Inc (VKTX) Be in Your Portfolio Monday? - InvestorsObserver - February 18th, 2024
- How the push to limit Chinese biotech could threaten U.S. edge - Axios - February 18th, 2024
- What is Biotechnology? Types and Applications - Iberdrola - January 25th, 2024
- BioAro Inc to Host Inaugural Longevity Innovation Forum in Dubai, UAE - Yahoo Finance - January 25th, 2024
- Is Akebia Therapeutics Inc (AKBA) a Bad Choice in Biotechnology Wednesday? - InvestorsObserver - January 25th, 2024
- Agricultural Biotechnology Market Projected to Reach USD 64.7 billion, with Advancing CAGR of 9.5% by 2031 ... - Yahoo Finance - January 25th, 2024
- Where Does Immunitybio Inc (IBRX) Stock Fall in the Biotechnology Field After It Is Lower By -9.32% This Week? - InvestorsObserver - January 25th, 2024
- Is Lyra Therapeutics Inc (LYRA) Stock at the Top of the Biotechnology Industry? - InvestorsObserver - January 25th, 2024
- ZWI Therapeutics Announces Closing of $10M Series A Financing - FinSMEs - January 25th, 2024
- Breaking Barriers: Tiamat Sciences Shatters Norms with All-Female Executive Team - Yahoo Finance - January 25th, 2024
- Can Sana Biotechnology Inc (SANA) Stock Rise to the Top of Healthcare Sector Monday? - InvestorsObserver - January 25th, 2024
- Is Cabaletta Bio Inc (CABA) a Leader in the Biotechnology Industry? - InvestorsObserver - January 25th, 2024
- Should You Buy Sana Biotechnology Inc (SANA) Stock After it Has Fallen 15.41% in a Week? - InvestorsObserver - January 25th, 2024
- Why Investors and Media are Calling Biotech Showcase The Place to Be to Start the Year - Business Wire - January 25th, 2024
- Is IGC Pharma Inc (IGC) Stock at the Top of the Biotechnology Industry? - InvestorsObserver - January 25th, 2024
- Is Summit Therapeutics Inc (SMMT) a Leader in the Biotechnology Industry? - InvestorsObserver - January 25th, 2024
- Biotech Stocks: The Top 5 To Watch As Shares Trend Down - Investor's Business Daily - January 25th, 2024
- Where Does Tscan Therapeutics Inc (TCRX) Stock Fall in the Biotechnology Field After It Is Lower By -9.81% This Week? - InvestorsObserver - January 25th, 2024
- HRMY: Are These 3 Biotech Stocks Worth Buying? - StockNews.com - January 25th, 2024
- Global Preparative Chromatography Market is projected to reach US$ 2,139.4 Million by 2034 Amid Growing ... - Yahoo Finance - January 25th, 2024
- Is Immunome Inc (IMNM) a Leader in the Biotechnology Industry? - InvestorsObserver - January 25th, 2024
- Should Biotechnology Stock Mink Therapeutics Inc (INKT) Be in Your Portfolio Monday? - InvestorsObserver - May 9th, 2023
- Where Does Ambrx Biopharma Inc - ADR (AMAM) Stock Fall in the Biotechnology Field After It Has Risen 22.18% This Week? - InvestorsObserver - May 9th, 2023
- Should Biotechnology Stock Dermata Therapeutics Inc (DRMA) Be in Your Portfolio Thursday? - InvestorsObserver - May 9th, 2023
- Should Biotechnology Stock Tempest Therapeutics Inc (TPST) Be in Your Portfolio Wednesday? - InvestorsObserver - May 9th, 2023
- Biotechnology - Applications of biotechnology | Britannica - May 1st, 2023
- Where Does BioLine RX Ltd - ADR (BLRX) Stock Fall in the Biotechnology Field After It Is Down -3.67% This Week? - InvestorsObserver - May 1st, 2023
- Where Does Apellis Pharmaceuticals Inc (APLS) Stock Fall in the Biotechnology Field After It Is Higher By 4.17% This Week? - InvestorsObserver - May 1st, 2023
- Where Does Aldeyra Therapeutics Inc (ALDX) Stock Fall in the Biotechnology Field After It Is Lower By -11.45% This Week? - InvestorsObserver - May 1st, 2023
- Is Rain Oncology Inc (RAIN) Stock at the Top of the Biotechnology Industry? - InvestorsObserver - April 7th, 2023
- Does Sana Biotechnology Inc (SANA) Have What it Takes to be in Your Portfolio Tuesday? - InvestorsObserver - April 7th, 2023
- Where Does Ambrx Biopharma Inc - ADR (AMAM) Stock Fall in the Biotechnology Field After It Is Lower By -15.43% This Week? - InvestorsObserver - April 7th, 2023
- Where Does Protagonist Therapeutics Inc (PTGX) Stock Fall in the Biotechnology Field After It Has Risen 3.62% This Week? - InvestorsObserver - April 7th, 2023
- What is Biotechnology? Definition, Types and Applications | TechTarget - March 21st, 2023
- Where Does Novavax Inc (NVAX) Stock Fall in the Biotechnology Field After It Is Lower By -12.99% This Week? - InvestorsObserver - March 21st, 2023