Alameda County Superior Court Judge Jo-Lynne Q. Lee set a hearing on nationally recognized plaintiffs firm Maune Raichle French Hartley & Mudd. LLCs motion for protective order in a pending asbestos case in which the defendants experts wanted to perform genetic testing. The case is John Lohmann and Suzanne Lohmann v. Aaon, Inc., et al. Alameda County Superior Court Case No. RG21098862. In this case, the plaintiffs filed their action in May 2021 in Alameda County against several defendants alleging that Mr. Lohmann contracted mesothelioma occupationally during his career as a refrigeration equipment mechanic beginning in the early 1970s largely in California.
After appearing in the action, the defendants retained pathology experts who wanted to use Mr. Lohmanns medical data for non-litigation purposes without Mr. Lohmanns permission, because the experts believed that the information would advance science. To conduct this testing, counsel for designated defense counsel moved for discovery of Mr. Lohmanns original cytology/pathology slides and paraffin blocks and subpoenaed his health care providers. The court ordered production of those original materials. According to the plaintiffs counsel, production of Mr. Lohmanns pathology and genetic material during litigation does not thereby permit outside, personal research and analysis. Multiple defendants disagreed, however, and contend that evidence produced during litigation enters the public domain and is thereafter not protected by discovery law.
As a result, on January 7, 2022 the plaintiffs filed for a protective order under California Code of Civil Procedure 2025.420, arguing that they never discussed with defense counsel the terms by which Mr. Lohmanns pathology material was to be used. The plaintiffs asked Alameda County Superior Court to block defendants from compiling medical data for the benefit of a third partys medical database or research project. Defendants, in their written opposition and during oral argument, contend that there is no authority barring medical research on data derived during litigation. Defendants also contend that the plaintiffs are incorrectly relying on Californias discovery statutes, which only govern how the evidence is obtained, not how it can be used. Defendants also argue that research evidence derived from litigation is relevant not only for diagnosis, treatment, and cause, but also helps determine the plaintiffs damages. For example, the defendants cite to scientific research showing that patients with the BAP-1 mesothelioma marker respond better to treatment and tend to have longer life expectancies than those patients without this marker. Defendants wish to present this evidence to the jury as they decide Mr. Lohmanns claim for future medical costs and damages for shortened life expectancy.
Up until last year, defendants and the plaintiffs in Alameda County operated under an informal discovery agreement regarding a plaintiffs pathology materials. However, with more and more defense experts looking to see if a plaintiff, like Mr. Lohmann, had the BAP-1 mesothelioma marker, the Maune firm revoked this informal agreement citing privacy and concerns over genetic testing of their clients materials. Their concerns were largely centered on the actions of longtime defense pathology expert, Dr. Victor Roggli, who published an article in 2020 describing an individual previously represented by the Maune firm.[1] According to the Maune firm, Dr. Rogglis use of their clients medical data in his non-litigation research was improper. In regard to the testing for BAP-1 in particular, the plaintiffs in Lohmann are attempting to block it arguing that it has questionable value in a mesothelioma case. The plaintiffs imply in their motion that the defendants are hoping to use published research linking BAP-1 mutations and certain asbestos exposures in litigation.
It is now up to Alameda County Superior Court to decide whether these defendants and the Dr. Rogglis of the world can, legally under the Discovery Act, use a plaintiffs medical data for their own non-litigation purposes without first obtaining the plaintiffs permission. The Court has requested additional briefing from the parties on this subject before it will make this determination. Defendants are urging the Court to retain an independent expert to examine this issue.
For the Lohmann case, the hearing on the plaintiffs protective order did not go forward after the Defendants stipulated that none of their experts intended to use any of Mr. Lohmanns medical information outside of litigation.
So, for now at least, this issue has been tabled until the next case. But, if and when Alameda County does make a ruling on this issue, its decision will have a significant impact on genetic defenses for mesothelioma cases in California and, likely, elsewhere in the nation as well. The courts eventual opinion will decide whether asbestos defendants can use a plaintiffs medical data in third-party research that could potentially help gather information useful to defendants defenses to damages claims in future asbestos cases.
[1] Mujahed T, Tazelaar HD, Sukov WR, Halling KC, Davila JI, Glass C, Pavlisko EN, Strickland KC, Roggli V, Haque M, Mneimneh W, Carter E, Galateau-Salle F, Glidden D, Garcia-Kennedy R, Larsen BT. Malignant Peritoneal Mesothelioma Arising in Young Adults With Long-standing Indwelling Intra-abdominal Shunt Catheters. Am J Surg Pathol. 2021 Feb 1;45(2):255-262. doi: 10.1097/PAS.0000000000001574. PMID: 32826527.
Original post:
Alameda County Awaits Key Decision Regarding The Use of Genetic Testing in Asbestos Cases - JD Supra
- Is ALS Hereditary? Genetics, Inheritance Patterns, and More - Healthline - May 5th, 2024
- Leveraging functional genomic annotations and genome coverage to improve polygenic prediction of complex traits ... - Nature.com - May 5th, 2024
- Genetic association of inflammatory marker GlycA with lung function and respiratory diseases - Nature.com - May 5th, 2024
- Exome sequencing reveals genetic heterogeneity and clinically actionable findings in children with cerebral palsy - Nature.com - May 5th, 2024
- Investigation of inherited noncoding genetic variation impacting the pharmacogenomics of childhood acute ... - Nature.com - May 5th, 2024
- Pitfalls in the genetic testing of the OPN1LW-OPN1MW gene cluster in human subjects | npj Genomic Medicine - Nature.com - May 5th, 2024
- Reply to: Pitfalls in the genetic testing of the OPN1LW-OPN1MW gene cluster in human subjects | npj Genomic Medicine - Nature.com - May 5th, 2024
- Lifespan is influenced more by lifestyle than genetics - Earth.com - May 5th, 2024
- Scientists discover over 100 new genomic regions linked to blood pressure - National Institutes of Health (NIH) (.gov) - May 5th, 2024
- Genetics studies have a diversity problem that researchers struggle to fix - The Lund Report - May 5th, 2024
- Researchers discover the genetic cause of the most common brain malformation - EL PAS USA - May 5th, 2024
- Genetic link between adolescent drinking and adult anxiety may offer therapy target | UIC today - UIC Today - May 5th, 2024
- Phylogenomics and genetic analysis of solvent-producing Clostridium species | Scientific Data - Nature.com - May 5th, 2024
- New genes are involved in the adaptation of acorn barnacles to sessile life - Nature.com - May 5th, 2024
- Rachel Khong explores genetics, race and the idea of being American in new novel - Wyoming Public Media - May 5th, 2024
- Genetic testing led to early cancer detection for father, daughter - Roswell Park Comprehensive Cancer Center - May 5th, 2024
- EYE ON HEALTH: High risk and genetic testing being offered at local hospital - Local 3 News - May 5th, 2024
- Fatty Liver: Is It Hereditary? - Healthline - May 5th, 2024
- Southern Seven Health Department to expand genetic cancer testing - KFVS - May 5th, 2024
- Genetic associations of key genes in breast cancer pathogenesis - News-Medical.Net - May 5th, 2024
- Mating Study Unlocks the Genetic Code of Attraction - Neuroscience News - March 18th, 2024
- Mindfulness in your DNA? Capacity to be present is partly a function of genetics, study finds - PsyPost - March 18th, 2024
- Genetic testing scam targets Medicare recipients, including those in Spokane - KXLY Spokane - March 18th, 2024
- Some people are genetically predisposed to gain weight. These 5 tips can help - CNN - March 18th, 2024
- SOPHiA GENETICS and The French Kidney Cancer Research Network (UroCCR) Publish Results from Multiyear ... - PR Newswire - March 18th, 2024
- Tissue samples show the deep genetic and cellular impacts of smoking - Medical Xpress - March 18th, 2024
- The regulatory landscape of chromatin accessibility - Nature.com - March 18th, 2024
- Genome assemblies of 11 bamboo species highlight diversification induced by dynamic subgenome dominance - Nature.com - March 18th, 2024
- Research reveals the genetic code behind non-identical twins - Medical Xpress - March 18th, 2024
- How genetic therapies transformed the lives of sickle cell patients - KPVI News 6 - March 18th, 2024
- The Next Wave of Privacy Litigation: The Illinois Genetic Information Privacy Act - Perkins Coie - March 18th, 2024
- State initiates study on genetic cancers, Lynch Syndrome - The Times of India - March 18th, 2024
- How genetic therapies transformed the lives of sickle cell patients - Citizentribune - March 18th, 2024
- Dr Plichta on Areas of Interest for Genetic Testing Research in Breast Cancer - OncLive - March 18th, 2024
- The Genetic History of the Jews Mosaic - Mosaic - March 18th, 2024
- New insights into genetic mechanisms could improve treatment of liver fibrosis - Medical Xpress - March 18th, 2024
- 5 Questions To Ask About The Ethics Of Genetic Data - Forbes - March 18th, 2024
- Couple raising money to fix sons club feet caused by rare genetic condition - 21 Alive News - February 18th, 2024
- What can bulls tell us about men? Genetic discovery could translate to human fertility research - Medical Xpress - February 18th, 2024
- Legislation seeks to bar life insurance companies from purchasing recreational genetic testing data - Delaware First Media - February 18th, 2024
- Family-based study identifies potential new genetic factors linked to Alzheimer's risk in people with African ancestry - National Institute on Aging - February 18th, 2024
- Genetic determinants of micronucleus formation in vivo - Nature.com - February 18th, 2024
- Near-gapless and haplotype-resolved apple genomes provide insights into the genetic basis of rootstock-induced ... - Nature.com - February 18th, 2024
- Accurate and sensitive mutational signature analysis with MuSiCal - Nature.com - February 18th, 2024
- CRISPR, the Genetic Revolution of the 21st Century | OpenMind - BBVA OpenMind - February 18th, 2024
- Genetic control of thermomorphogenesis in tomato inflorescences - Nature.com - February 18th, 2024
- Natural selection and genetic diversity maintenance in a parasitic wasp during continuous biological control application - Nature.com - February 18th, 2024
- Understanding how natural genetic variation contributes to adaptive responses to low oxygen - News-Medical.Net - February 18th, 2024
- Division of Epidemiology and Genetics - Epidemiology and Genetics - University of Southern California - February 18th, 2024
- Genetic study clarifies the link between birth weight and adult morbidity - Medical Xpress - February 18th, 2024
- AI and genetics underpin project to speed up CVD diagnosis and personalise treatment - Hospital Healthcare - February 18th, 2024
- Study Reveals Complex Interaction Between Genetics and Environment in Brain Functioning - Medriva - February 18th, 2024
- Unraveling the Impact of Genetics and Socioeconomic Status on Behavioral and Psychiatric Traits - Medriva - February 18th, 2024
- Genetic Investigation Reveals CETP Gene Variants Linked to Cardiovascular Resilience in Genome-Wide Association ... - Physician's Weekly - December 30th, 2023
- Raha Kapoor's blue eyes remind fans of her great-grandfather, Raj Kapoor; here's what genetics says - IndiaTimes - December 30th, 2023
- Genetic clue to pericarditis inflammation points to promising new treatments - News-Medical.Net - December 30th, 2023
- Certain genetic predispositions may increase risk of atrial fibrillation among those with high alcohol consumption - 2 Minute Medicine - December 30th, 2023
- Understanding the genetic basis of hereditary diffuse gastric cancer - News-Medical.Net - December 30th, 2023
- Genetic engineering was meant to save chestnut trees. Then there was a mistake. - The Washington Post - December 30th, 2023
- Unraveling the mystery of hereditary diffuse gastric cancer - EurekAlert - December 30th, 2023
- What is Genetics? | AMNH - American Museum of Natural History - December 22nd, 2023
- Who killed Shelley Connolly? Genetic genealogy leads authorities to a suspect and a conviction - Alaska's News Source - December 22nd, 2023
- C.S. Lewis, Atheism, and the Genetic Fallacy - Word on Fire - December 22nd, 2023
- FDA approves first genetic test to assess opioid addiction risk using DNA sample - Fox News - December 22nd, 2023
- Genetic blueprint of wild grapes could help breed better grapes - University of California, Davis - December 22nd, 2023
- Unlocking the genetic secrets of grape seedlessness - Phys.org - December 22nd, 2023
- Unlocking the genetic secrets of drought resilience in Persian walnuts - Phys.org - December 22nd, 2023
- FDA approves genetic test to assess patients risk of developing an opioid addiction - KXAN.com - December 22nd, 2023
- How researchers are CReATiNG synthetic chromosomes faster and cheaper - EurekAlert - December 22nd, 2023
- The promise of genetic therapies in sickle cell disease - The Lancet - December 22nd, 2023
- Assessment of genetic diversity, population structure and wolf-dog hybridisation in the Eastern Romanian Carpathian ... - Nature.com - December 22nd, 2023
- Genetics and Heart Disease: What you need to know - IndiaTimes - December 22nd, 2023
- How to become a geneticist - University of Sydney - December 22nd, 2023
- Study sheds light on the ancestry and genetics of Coast Salish woolly dogs | News | Vancouver Island University ... - Vancouver Island University News - December 22nd, 2023
- Human genetics | Description, Chromosomes, & Inheritance - December 13th, 2023
- BASIC GENETICS INFORMATION - Understanding Genetics - NCBI Bookshelf - December 13th, 2023
- Introduction to Genetics - Open Textbook Library - December 13th, 2023
- Clues to preventing Alzheimer's come from patient who, despite genetics, evaded disease Washington University ... - Washington University School of... - December 13th, 2023
- Environmental stress rather than genetics influenced height differences in early Neolithic people: Study - Phys.org - December 13th, 2023
- What is trisomy 18? Why the fatal genetic disorder is in the news and what it's like to get the diagnosis. - Yahoo Life - December 13th, 2023