Reports of reinfection with the coronavirus evoke a nightmarish future: Repeat bouts of illness, impotent vaccines, unrelenting lockdowns a pandemic without an end.
A case study published on Monday, about a 25-year-old man in Nevada, has stoked those fears anew. The man, who was not named, became sicker the second time that he was infected with the virus, a pattern the immune system is supposed to prevent.
But these cases make the news precisely because they are rare, experts said: More than 38 million people worldwide have been infected with the coronavirus, and as of Monday, fewer than five of those cases have been confirmed by scientists to be reinfections.
Thats tiny its like a microliter-sized drop in the bucket, compared to the number of cases that have happened all over the world, said Angela Rasmussen, a virologist at Columbia University in New York.
In most cases, a second bout with the virus produced milder symptoms or none at all. But for at least three people, including one patient in Ecuador, the illness was more severe the second time around than during the first infection. An 89-year-old woman in the Netherlands died during her second illness.
Rare as these cases may be, they do indicate that reinfection is possible, said Akiko Iwasaki, an immunologist at Yale University, who wrote a commentary accompanying the Nevada case study, published in The Lancet Infectious Diseases.
Its important to note that there are people who do get reinfected, and in some of those cases you get worse disease, Dr. Iwasaki said. You still need to keep wearing masks and practice social distancing even if you have recovered once from this infection.
We asked experts what is known about reinfections with the coronavirus, and what the phenomenon means for vaccinations and the course of the pandemic.
First, the good news: Reinfection seems to be vanishingly rare.
Since the first confirmed case of reinfection, reported in Hong Kong on Aug. 24, there have been three published cases; reports of another 20 await scientific review.
But its impossible to know exactly how widespread the phenomenon is. To confirm a case of reinfection, scientists must look for significant differences in the genes of the two coronaviruses causing both illnesses.
In the United States, where testing was a rare resource much of this year, many people were not tested unless they were sick enough to be hospitalized. Even then, their samples were usually not preserved for genetic analysis, making it impossible to confirm suspected reinfections.
A vast majority of people who do get reinfected may go undetected. For example, the man in Hong Kong had no symptoms the second time, and his infection was discovered only because of routine screening at the airport.
There are a lot of people that are going to also have been exposed that arent having symptoms, that were never going to hear about, said Marion Pepper, an immunologist at the University of Washington in Seattle.
People whose second infections are more severe are more likely to be identified, because they return to the hospital. But those are likely to be even rarer, experts said.
If this was a very common event, we would have seen thousands of cases, Dr. Iwasaki said.
Reinfections can occur for any number of reasons: because the initial infection was too mild to produce an immune response, for example, or because the immune system was compromised by other health conditions. On occasion, a patient may be exposed to a large amount of virus that seeded an infection before the immune response could respond.
This variability is entirely expected, experts said, and has been observed in patients with diseases like measles and malaria.
Youll never have the distribution of anything with millions of people where you dont have some very severe rare cases happening at the fringe, said Dr. Michael Mina, a pediatric immunologist at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health.
At least two of the reinfected patients in Europe had compromised immune systems, for example, and the 89-year-old woman who died was receiving chemotherapy. In other reinfected patients, genetic factors or the lack of certain previous immune exposures may have blunted the bodys ability to fight off a second attack.
There are some people who just dont develop good immune responses to certain pathogens, said Florian Krammer, an immunologist at the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai. What is causing that? Were not sure, but its rare, usually.
In a vast majority of known infected patients, experts said, the immune system functions as it should against other pathogens.
There are a lot of different infections where you can get re-exposed to the virus, and we would probably not know because you dont have symptoms, Dr. Pepper said. And that might be an important part of boosting immunity.
When the body is exposed to an unfamiliar virus, its normal first to develop some immunity and then to increase that response with each additional exposure. This phenomenon is well known among children, but it is less often seen in adults because they rarely encounter new viruses, Dr. Mina said.
I think its important to recognize that reinfections are literally embedded in the evolution of our immune system, he added. We sometimes lose track of that with so many people talking about this who really havent studied the immune system.
For every confirmed case of reinfection, there are dozens of anecdotal reports of infected people who were sick and seemingly recovered but then became ill again weeks to months later.
Usually there are crucial data missing in those cases, like a confirmed lab diagnosis, or a virus sample that can be sequenced.
The question is always, Is it a real reinfection? Dr. Krammer said. Its very often very challenging to kind of get that kind of data.
A vast majority of these cases are unlikely to be true infections. More likely, these are people experiencing a resurgence of symptoms connected to the original infection. The virus may set off an inflammatory response that can flare up even weeks later and cause symptoms like fatigue and heart problems. In rare cases, some patients may develop a chronic low-grade infection with the virus that never quite goes away.
Even with viruses that can cause acute infections, like flu, Dr. Krammer said, you can have persistent infections if your immune system is sufficiently compromised.
Although these are not real reinfections, they are still worrying if they lead to renewed illness or hospitalization months after the initial infection, Dr. Rasmussen said. If theres recrudescence happening frequently, and people are getting severely ill the second time around, thats potentially its own problem, she said.
Reinfected people without symptoms may still transmit the virus to others. The patient in Hong Kong, for example, was isolated in a hospital even though he had no symptoms. But his viral load was high enough that he could have passed the virus to others.
Obviously, that person wasnt ill, so it bodes well for him, but it doesnt bode well for the community, Dr. Pepper said.
But to be sure of infectiousness, researchers may need to look for live virus. South Korean researchers investigated hundreds of reports of reinfection and were able to rule them out as real cases after failing to grow infectious virus from the samples.
Similar procedures would be needed to rule out the possibility of transmission in each patient, Dr. Rasmussen said, adding, I think thats the only way youd be able to get to the bottom of that.
Reports of reinfection have raised concerns about whether vaccines for the coronavirus will be effective and help communities achieve population immunity. The worry is that the immunity produced by vaccines will not be sufficient in preventing reinfections with the virus.
In reality, experts said, vaccines have a better chance at generating robust immunity than does natural infection with the virus.
For example, the coronavirus is particularly adept at dodging the bodys early immune alarms, buying valuable time to seed an infection. In some people, this lag eventually triggers a cascading immune overreaction that can be more harmful than the infection itself.
Vaccines are intended to unfurl an immune response without interference from the virus, and thus may avoid this inflammatory sequence. Vaccines can also be manipulated to enhance immune memory, in that way producing more lasting, more protective responses.
Vaccine trials are designed to look for an absence of disease, rather than of infection, and its unclear whether vaccines can suppress virus levels enough to prevent transmission to others.
Still, vaccine-induced immunity should perform better than natural immunity, Dr. Rasmussen said, adding, Im optimistic.
Originally posted here:
Coronavirus Reinfections Are Real but Very, Very Rare - The New York Times
- Sjogren's Disease Symptoms - Dry Mouth & Eyes | NIAMS - June 11th, 2025
- Why don't bats get cancer? Researchers discover protection from genes and strong immune systems - Phys.org - June 11th, 2025
- HIV/AIDS: Facts about the viral infection that attacks the immune system - Live Science - June 11th, 2025
- SARS-CoV-2 protein found to spread between cells, triggering immune attack on healthy cells - Medical Xpress - June 11th, 2025
- Study reveals mechanisms behind antibiotic-related immune disruptions in infants - News-Medical - June 11th, 2025
- Israeli scientists discover immune cells that both fight and fuel breast cancer - The Times of Israel - June 11th, 2025
- One thing everyone should know about innate immunity - Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health - June 11th, 2025
- Immune System - National Institutes of Health (NIH) | (.gov) - June 11th, 2025
- Pseudomonas aeruginosa-derived metabolites and volatile organic compounds: impact on lung epithelial homeostasis and mucosal immune response -... - June 11th, 2025
- Discovery Suggests Method to Offset Antibiotic-Caused Harm to Infant Immune Systems - PR Newswire - June 11th, 2025
- Modified CAR-T cells target widespread protein found in multiple types of cancer - Medical Xpress - June 11th, 2025
- Indian team uncovers how the immune system brakes when viruses team up - India Today - June 11th, 2025
- COVID boosters do not harm T-cell function in the vulnerable - News-Medical - June 11th, 2025
- Atherosclerosis: from lipid-lowering and anti-inflammatory therapies to targeting arterial retention of ApoB-containing lipoproteins - Frontiers - June 11th, 2025
- New study reveals the cellular network behind food tolerance and allergies - The Jerusalem Post - June 11th, 2025
- As COVID cases rise again, the top three things you must do to strengthen your immunity - The Economic Times - June 11th, 2025
- 2025-06 - Getting the message from particles to protection - Wits University - June 11th, 2025
- Alopecia Areata - Hair loss Causes & Living With It | NIAMS - June 3rd, 2025
- Atopic Dermatitis Treatment, Symptoms & Causes | NIAMS - June 3rd, 2025
- Psoriasis Types, Symptoms & Causes | NIAMS - June 3rd, 2025
- Autoimmune Diseases | NIAMS - June 3rd, 2025
- Neoantigens combined with in situ cancer vaccination induce personalized immunity and reshape the tumor microenvironment - Nature - June 3rd, 2025
- Systemic Lupus Erythematosus (Lupus): Diagnosis, Treatment, and Steps ... - June 3rd, 2025
- What Is Scleroderma? Symptoms & Causes| NIAMS - June 3rd, 2025
- Vision, Immune System Studies and Hardware Inspections Keep Crew Busy - NASA (.gov) - June 3rd, 2025
- Vitamin C, anyone? The truth about immunity boosters - The Times - June 3rd, 2025
- COVID-19 vaccination atlas using an integrative systems vaccinology approach - Nature - June 3rd, 2025
- Key to treating Alzheimers may lie within immune system, UVA researchers say - WVIR - June 3rd, 2025
- Study says original COVID-19 vaccination did not stop immune system from fighting variants - The University of Arizona Health Sciences - June 3rd, 2025
- Engineered viruses and gene therapy halt tumor growth and extend survival in mice - News-Medical - June 3rd, 2025
- Integrated lncRNA and mRNA analysis reveals the immune modulatory mechanisms of antimicrobial peptide BSN-37 in mouse peritoneal macrophages - Nature - June 3rd, 2025
- Neuro-immune crosstalk in cancer: mechanisms and therapeutic implications - Nature - June 3rd, 2025
- Research Spotlight: New Therapeutic Approach Stops Glioblastoma from Hijacking the Immune System - Mass General Brigham - June 3rd, 2025
- To fight HIV, antibodies boost the immune system - drugdiscoverynews.com - June 3rd, 2025
- Innovative technology simplifies T cell harvesting for cancer immunotherapy - News-Medical - June 3rd, 2025
- Daily briefing: Immune cell spies give the brain information about the gut - Nature - June 3rd, 2025
- Innovative treatment uses patients own immune system to fight cancer - The Independent - June 3rd, 2025
- Eosinophil innate immune memory after bacterial skin infection promotes allergic lung inflammation - Science | AAAS - April 5th, 2025
- Researchers Discover mRNA Vaccines Leave Lasting Mark on the Immune System - SciTechDaily - April 5th, 2025
- Scientific Journeys: Uncovering how dioxins affect the immune system - National Institutes of Health (NIH) (.gov) - April 5th, 2025
- Oligodendroglial precursor cells modulate immune response and early demyelination in a murine model of multiple sclerosis - Science | AAAS - April 5th, 2025
- Measles can ravage the immune system and brain, causing long-term damage a virologist explains - The Conversation - April 5th, 2025
- Microscopic Instigators - The University of New Mexico - April 5th, 2025
- Changes in the immune index before and after surgery in urinary malignancy patients with AIDS - Nature - April 5th, 2025
- Non-immune targeting of CXCR3 compromises mitochondrial function and suppresses tumor growth in glioblastoma - Nature - April 5th, 2025
- 8 Supplements That Will Boost Your Immune System - Verywell Health - April 5th, 2025
- Improving immunotherapy for the treatment of hepatocellular carcinoma: learning from patients and preclinical models - Nature - April 5th, 2025
- Redefining the immune landscape of hepatitis A virus infection - Nature - April 5th, 2025
- What Happens to Your Immune Health When You Take Vitamin C and Zinc Together? - Verywell Health - April 5th, 2025
- Diet Has A Major Impact On The Immune System - WorldHealth.net - April 5th, 2025
- Top 7 ways to boost your immune system - The Indian Express - April 5th, 2025
- Kinetics of pIgR and IgM immune responses in snakehead ( Channa argus ) to inactivated Aeromonas hydrophila via immersion and intraperitoneal... - April 5th, 2025
- What Is Man Flu? - Cleveland Clinic Health Essentials - April 5th, 2025
- Dynamics of T cell subpopulations and plasma cytokines during the first year of antineoplastic therapy in patients with breast cancer: the BEGYN-1... - April 5th, 2025
- Publication in npj Vaccines Reports Cross-reactive and Long-Lasting Immune Responses for self-amplifying mRNA (samRNA) COVID-19 Vaccine Booster... - April 5th, 2025
- 9 Supplements, Tonics, and Oils to Boost Immune Health - W Magazine - April 5th, 2025
- Preoperative pan-immuno-inflammatory values and albumin-to-globulin ratio predict the prognosis of stage IIII colorectal cancer - Nature - April 5th, 2025
- Systemic Lupus Erythematosus (Lupus) - Who gets it? | NIAMS - February 7th, 2025
- Systemic Lupus Erythematosus (Lupus) Basics - National Institute of ... - February 7th, 2025
- Long COVID: women at greater risk compared to men could immune system differences be the cause? - The Conversation - February 7th, 2025
- What is Pemphigus? Symptoms & Causes | NIAMS - February 7th, 2025
- How the immune system influences pancreatic cancer: New interactions provide therapeutic insights - Medical Xpress - February 7th, 2025
- Mitochondrias Secret Power Unleashed in the Battle Against Inflammation - SciTechDaily - February 7th, 2025
- WNT11 Promotes immune evasion and resistance to Anti-PD-1 therapy in liver metastasis - Nature.com - February 7th, 2025
- The role of the behavioral immune system in the expression of short and long-term orientation in young Chilean men during the COVID-19 pandemic - BMC... - February 7th, 2025
- Harvard nutritionist eats these 5 foods to keep her 'immune system strong' and 'energy high' - CNBC - February 7th, 2025
- Micro Immune Response On-chip (MIRO) models the tumour-stroma interface for immunotherapy testing - Nature.com - February 7th, 2025
- Personalized Therapeutic Vaccine Steers the Immune System to Fight Kidney Cancer | Newswise - Newswise - February 7th, 2025
- Identification of m6A methyltransferase-related WTAP and ZC3H13 predicts immune infiltrates in glioblastoma - Nature.com - February 7th, 2025
- Serotonin attenuates tumor necrosis factor-induced intestinal inflammation by interacting with human mucosal tissue - Nature.com - February 7th, 2025
- Identification of the immune infiltration and biomarkers in ulcerative colitis based on liquidliquid phase separation-related genes - Nature.com - February 7th, 2025
- FLASH radiation reprograms lipid metabolism and macrophage immunity and sensitizes medulloblastoma to CAR-T cell therapy - Nature.com - February 7th, 2025
- Young Innovators: U of S researcher uses bat immune systems to find next generation therapies - Saskatoon Star-Phoenix - February 7th, 2025
- World Cancer Day 2025: Chronic stress, immune system, and cancer risk- How are these connected? - The Times of India - February 7th, 2025
- New research unlocks key to long-lasting immune response in cancer and chronic diseases - The Peter Doherty Institute for Infection and Immunity - February 7th, 2025
- Microbial Dynamics and Immune Response to NTHi in COPD - Physician's Weekly - February 7th, 2025
- MHE Week in Review RFK Jr. Spotlight - Managed Healthcare Executive - February 7th, 2025
- Psoriasis Basics: Overview, Symptoms, and Causes - January 27th, 2025
- Vitiligo Symptoms, Treatment & Causes | NIAMS - January 27th, 2025
- The Surprising Connection Between Obesity, Parasites, and Your Immune System - SciTechDaily - January 27th, 2025