"La rptition au foyer de la danse" (ca. 1870-1872) is included in the Musee d'Orsay's exhibition "Degas at the Opera."
"La rptition au foyer de la danse" (ca. 1870-1872) is included in the Musee d'Orsay's exhibition "Degas at the Opera."
Photo: Edgar Degas/The Phillips Collection
"La rptition au foyer de la danse" (ca. 1870-1872) is included in the Musee d'Orsay's exhibition "Degas at the Opera."
"La rptition au foyer de la danse" (ca. 1870-1872) is included in the Musee d'Orsay's exhibition "Degas at the Opera."
Degas had a gift for conveying the truth - even when he was making it all up
PARIS - Fake news and truth, the terms we hear so much about lately, are supposed to be mutually exclusive. Truth is obdurate and aloof. Fake is fake: It's a sham. Simpering and obscene, it demeans everyone it touches.
We want - we need - the distinction to be clear-cut, since so much rides on it. But in the realm of art (isn't it always so?) things are more complicated.
Take Edgar Degas, whose work is now the subject of a sprawling, stupendous show, "Degas at the Opra," at the Muse d'Orsay. (It will travel in modified form to the National Gallery of Art next year.)
Degas is supposed to have been on the side of truth. But truth in art and truth in public life are very different things. And we get Degas badly wrong if we mistake him for a documentarian.
The standard Degas narrative is that he dispensed with the stale repertoire of religious, mythological and historical subjects and turned his gaze instead to contemporary life: the city's racetrack, cafe concerts, milliners' shops, brothels and ballet classes. Everyone knows, too, that Degas helped form the Impressionist group - and what was Impressionism about if not showing the world as it is?
That story is fine as far as it goes. But neat stories - especially those involving sunlight and poppy fields - don't really adhere to Degas. He was an indoor creature, slightly vampiric, ferociously independent. ("If I were the government," he once said, "I would have a special brigade of gendarmes to keep an eye on artists who paint landscapes from nature. Oh, I don't mean to kill anyone; just a little dose of birdshot now and then as a warning." And you want to call this guy an Impressionist?)
In the century since Degas's death, the idea that he embraced Impressionist-style spontaneity and natural light has been hard to shake. So has the notion that he was an intrepid realist haunting the hidden corners of Paris. But when we look at Degas through the lens of the one subject that dominated his oeuvre - the Paris Opra - both notions finally fall apart.
Unlike other subjects, which Degas treated only sporadically, the Opra was a continuous subject for about four decades. As you move from one image to the next in this show (which was organized by Degas biographer Henri Loyrette, with the assistance of Leila Jarbouai and Marine Kisiel of the Muse d'Orsay and Kimberly Jones of the National Gallery), you could be fooled into imagining that Degas was giving you a brisk tour of the Opra building:
Here is the stage ... There is the orchestra ... Here are the dancers ... Here is where they rehearse ... And here is where the gentlemen subscribers in top hats come to procure sexual favors.
Surely not from those sweet ballerinas in tutus?
The "little rats"? Yes, yes. From them.
Degas, however, was no tour guide. Nor was he a journalist. For him, it all went far, far deeper. Everything he did had an underlying aesthetic rationale. And everything was invented.
That's right: Degas was a fabulist. His art was a studio product. ("No art is less spontaneous than mine," he said.) It did not come from standing about in the fields like a damn cow. It came from hard work and imagination, and always drew from the Old Masters, toward whom Degas's reverence was palpable.
Even the settings of the Opra works were mostly invented: The first Paris opera house Degas came to know was on the rue Le Peletier. Already scheduled for demolition by the time he started attending, it was destroyed by fire in 1873. The fire kick-started the stalled construction of the new opera house, the opulent Palais Garnier (the famous setting for "The Phantom of the Opera"), which finally opened in 1875.
But Degas much preferred the old building, so he proceeded as if the Palais Garnier simply didn't exist: The identifiable settings of almost all his depictions of the Opra are in the destroyed building on the rue Le Peletier.
So much for truth-telling.
Casting off false notions about Degas frees us to perceive the Opra's significance to him. Certainly he was attracted to the music. (Degas was an aficionado, with sophisticated tastes. He loved 18th-century composers - Bach, Rameau and especially Gluck - and rejected the cult of Wagner then sweeping Europe.)
But the deeper reason the Opra seduced him as an artist stands in plain sight: It was a place of make-believe, of spectacle, of artifice. For Degas, according to Loyrette, it was "a closed universe," "a microcosm of infinite possibilities, allowing all kinds of experimentation."
Degas reveled in this. In his Opra pictures, he played with points of view and contrasts of light and dark; with movement and gesture; with cropping and composition; and with format, medium and scale.
The Opra's appeal must also have been psychological. Anyone who goes to the theater gets it immediately. Stage, backstage, curtains, scenery, audience: The atmosphere is infectious. You feel the thrill of voyeurism, the possibility of adopting alternative personas, the tart, vinegary taste of so much brazen artifice. (One thinks of Matisse describing the hotel rooms in Nice that he transformed into stage sets, decked out with Oriental fabrics and adorned with local models posing as odalisques: "Everything was fake, absurd, amazing, delicious.")
In his great essay "The Painter of Modern Life," Charles Baudelaire argued that beauty is composed of two equal parts. One part hinges on eternal values; the other is "relative, circumstantial" and plugged into the contingent present. Degas - perhaps even more convincingly than his friend douard Manet - met the challenge of how to express such beauty pictorially.
He united suggestions of an impersonal, Arcadian dream with an intense, streaming, present-tense intimacy. The intimacy burns cleanly, drawing its fuel from Romanticist color and movement and its oxygen from modern disjuncture. The Arcadian side of his work, meanwhile, draws on the timeless spell of ancient Greece (via Degas' hero, the neoclassicist J.-A.-D. Ingres).
Only the Opra gave Degas the license to bring all this together.
The first of his Opra-inspired works was an 1867 depiction of a well-known dancer, Eugnie Fiocre, on the set of a ballet, "La Source." For many years, the picture confused art historians, because it looks like a landscape - a mountain scene in the Caucasus, no less, replete with a horse drinking from a stream. All that gives it away as a stage set for a ballet is a pair of pink ballet slippers visible between the horse's front legs.
Over the next few years, Degas painted many astute portraits of singers and musicians. He made a breakthrough in 1870 with "The Orchestra at the Opera," a portrait commissioned by the bassoonist Dsir Dihau. It shows Dihau in his natural habitat - the orchestra pit at the Opra, surrounded by fellow musicians.
Degas returned repeatedly to this composition - the dark pit in the lower half, the colorful stage above. It looks spontaneous, but the tableau was entirely artificial. The bassoonist, for starters, would not have occupied a place in the orchestra's front row. Nor did the musicians sit at right angles to the stage.
So many incredible images unfurl like a Chinese scroll painting from these early breakthroughs. The most famous, of course, are the dancers. Degas depicted them stretching at the bar, retying their slippers or perched atop a grand piano while stretching and scratching their backs. Here again, though, he freely invented features of the rooms they occupy and concocted details of their activities. When he asked a friend, Albert Hecht, for a pass permitting him to see the weekly dance examinations, he sheepishly admitted: "I have done so many of these dance examinations without having seen them that I am a little ashamed of it."
Next door to the Opra was a brothel. Degas did not ignore the sad, seamy fact of their connection. Yet again, though, his vision was filtered through someone else's imaginings. Inspired by best-selling novellas by a friend, the librettist Ludovic Halvy (who collaborated with Bizet on "Carmen"), Degas depicted men propositioning the young dancers. Most were desperately poor, working-class girls. Those who trafficked in sex were often pimped by their own mothers. In a series of monotypes, Degas even takes us inside the brothel and - uncharacteristically - lets his revulsion show.
As he aged and his eyesight slowly deteriorated, Degas maintained his devotion to themes he had been inspired by at the Opra. Retreating from his earlier fascination with people as unique psychological entities immersed in social space, he turned instead to a more private vision. His late dancers (clumps of overlapping girls resembling many-limbed, many-headed monsters, weirdly endowed with their own interiority) amount to a kind of long and death-haunted monologue - obsessive, ravished and, in the annals of art, unprecedented.
- - -
"Degas at the Opera"
Through Jan. 19 at the Muse d'Orsay, Paris. musee-orsay.fr.
Original post:
Degas had a gift for conveying the truth - even when he was making it all up - Alton Telegraph
- Could my glasses be making my eyesight worse? - The Conversation - April 8th, 2024
- Eyeglasses Improve Income as Well as Sight, Study Shows - The New York Times - April 8th, 2024
- John Berger Lost His Eyesight to Cataracts and Learned to See - Hyperallergic - April 8th, 2024
- Eye Health Facts: What You Need to Know About the Eyes - Prevention Magazine - April 8th, 2024
- Reading glasses are good for your eyes and your income : Goats and Soda - NPR - April 8th, 2024
- 'The sight to fight:' Yorktown military members make thousands of glasses for the service - News 3 WTKR Norfolk - April 8th, 2024
- How to Watch the Solar Eclipse Without Damaging Your Eyes - Verywell Health - April 8th, 2024
- Protect Your Eyes While Watching the Solar EclipseExpert Advice from NYU Langone's Dr. Nitish Mehta - NYU Langone Health - April 8th, 2024
- 10 Daily Habits That Will Help You Protect Your Eye Health - CNET - January 25th, 2024
- Undergoing cataract surgery when it's not necessary? Some do it to improve their eyesight, but it's not without risk - The Conversation Indonesia - January 25th, 2024
- Sight Care Reviews - Is It Safe to Use? The Most Important Fact to Know Before Buy! - Kent Reporter - January 25th, 2024
- Apple has big and cartoonish plans for Vision Pro's EyeSight - AppleInsider - January 25th, 2024
- National Center for Children's Vision and Eye Health at Prevent Blindness Celebrates 15th Anniversary in 2024 - PR Web - January 25th, 2024
- Understanding Computer Vision Syndrome: Causes, Symptoms, and Practical Solutions - Medriva - January 25th, 2024
- 8 Eye Issues You Should Never Ignore - Right as Rain by UW Medicine - January 9th, 2024
- Digital eye strain is a growing issue as the muscles of the eyes work overtime, warn vision experts - Fox News - January 9th, 2024
- Know the Facts About Glaucoma - MedicineNet - January 9th, 2024
- New Year, New Vision: Top Resolutions For Optimal Eye Health - ABP Live - January 9th, 2024
- Childhood Myopia and Its Impact on Vision Loss: What Causes It? - News18 - January 9th, 2024
- What you see first in optical illusion can reveal a lot about you but youll need 20/20 vision to spot hi... - The Sun - January 9th, 2024
- The Importance of Eye Care: Preventing Vision Impairments and Maintaining Good Eye Health - Medriva - December 30th, 2023
- Six ways to look after your eyes in 2024 - The Conversation - December 30th, 2023
- 6 Essential Ways to Safeguard and Improve Your Vision in 2024 - Medriva - December 30th, 2023
- SightCare Reviews - Obvious Hoax or Safe Pills That Work? Fake Scams to Avoid | Courier-Herald - Enumclaw Courier-Herald - December 30th, 2023
- SightCare Reviews - Honest Customer Warning! Real Eyesight Support or Fake Hype? - Bothell-Kenmore Reporter - December 30th, 2023
- Global Intraocular Lens Market Surges with Innovations in Vision Correction | CAGR of 5.6% - PharmiWeb.com - December 30th, 2023
- Infection of the eye, and how to protect vision - The Hindu - December 30th, 2023
- Optical Illusion Eye Test: Can you find the dog in the street in 7 seconds? - Jagran Josh - December 30th, 2023
- You have 20/20 vision if you can find the hidden chick amongst these ducks - IndiaTimes - December 30th, 2023
- Eye Doc: Look *Here* While You Drive + 8 More Genius Tips to Improve Night Vision Behind The Wheel - Yahoo Life - December 22nd, 2023
- Designer creates inclusive clothing company after losing eyesight - Fox Business - December 22nd, 2023
- What is the state of American eyesight? - USAFacts - December 22nd, 2023
- When temporary vision loss in one eye isn't a sign of stroke - Harvard Health - December 22nd, 2023
- 10 Hacks That Can Naturally Boost Your Eye Health Today - CNET - December 22nd, 2023
- SightCare Reviews (Critical Customer Warning!) Know The Sight Care Facts Before Buy - Ukiah Daily Journal - December 22nd, 2023
- Everyone can spot the building with the hole in it but only those with 20/20 vision can find the giant C... - The US Sun - December 22nd, 2023
- Flashes, shimmers and blind spots: Here's what migraine aura looks like - The Washington Post - December 22nd, 2023
- Doctors Reveal the Snack That Cuts Your Risk of Vision-Clouding Cataracts in Half - Yahoo Life - December 22nd, 2023
- Yoga For Healthy Vision: 5 Extraordinary Yogasanas To Improve Eyesight - Netmeds.com - December 22nd, 2023
- Everyone can spot the teddy bears but you have 20/20 vision if you can see the bee in the bedroom in under... - The US Sun - December 22nd, 2023
- Reindeers blue eyes act as night vision goggles to help them find food in winter - The Guardian - December 22nd, 2023
- 6 Bad Habits That Could Be Damaging Your Eyesight - Money Talks News - December 22nd, 2023
- Reindeer vision may have evolved to spot favorite food in the snowy dark of winter - Phys.org - December 22nd, 2023
- Human eyes: How they work, and their amazing anatomy - BBC Science Focus Magazine - December 22nd, 2023
- Why reindeer eyes shine blue in the winter - The Washington Post - December 22nd, 2023
- Can Everyone Unfocus Their Eyes On Command? - IFLScience - December 22nd, 2023
- You have the eyes of a hunter if you can spot the dogs owner in the picture in 8 seconds! - Jagran Josh - December 22nd, 2023
- Everyone can see the Christmas trees but you could have 20/20 vision if you can spot the star hiding in t... - The US Sun - December 22nd, 2023
- Here's how eye exams can reveal several health conditions beyond your sight - The Record (New Westminster) - December 22nd, 2023
- At Bread for the Citys vision clinic, patients can see clearly now - The Washington Post - December 13th, 2023
- SightCare Reviews - Is Official Website for Sight Care Legit to Try or Scam (2024) | Vashon-Maury Island Beachcomber - Vashon-Maury Island Beachcomber - December 13th, 2023
- The Benefits of Donning Prescription Sunglasses for Vision Correction and Protection - Anti Aging News - December 13th, 2023
- Vision Pro training of Apple retail store employees to start soon - BGR - December 13th, 2023
- 6 Best Vitamins and Supplements for Healthy Eyes - CNET - December 13th, 2023
- Eye Health: How to Protect Eyes From Digital Strain, Vision Loss and More? 5 Tips - India.com - December 13th, 2023
- How to watch the solar eclipse without damaging your eyesight - WATE 6 On Your Side - October 16th, 2023
- Can Optical Illusions Improve Vision? Know The Best One That Benefits Eyesight - Times Now - May 17th, 2023
- Motus GI Announces Executive Leadership Restructuring and Additional Cost Saving Initiatives to Support Near-Term Milestones - April 15th, 2023
- Revolution Medicines to Participate in 22nd Annual Needham Healthcare Conference - April 15th, 2023
- GENFIT Reports Full-Year 2022 Financial Results and Provides Corporate Update - April 15th, 2023
- Kane Biotech to Release Fourth Quarter and Full Year 2022 Financial Results on April 20, 2023 – Conference Call to Follow - April 15th, 2023
- Biomea Fusion To Present Two Preclinical Posters at the 114th AACR Annual Meeting - April 15th, 2023
- Cabaletta Bio to Present at the 22nd Annual Needham Virtual Healthcare Conference - April 15th, 2023
- Syneos Health Schedules First Quarter 2023 Earnings Call for Wednesday, May 10th, 2023 - April 15th, 2023
- Oncternal Therapeutics Participating in Oppenheimer & Co.’s Virtual Fireside Chat: Discussion of ROR1 CAR T Cell Therapy in Hematological... - April 15th, 2023
- Travere Therapeutics Reports Inducement Grants Under Nasdaq Listing Rule 5635(c)(4) - April 15th, 2023
- Alvotech Provides Regulatory Update on AVT02 Biologics License Application - April 15th, 2023
- Vivoryon Therapeutics N.V. to Report Full Year 2022 Financial Results and Operational Progress on April 19, 2023 - April 15th, 2023
- Additional Future Royalty Revenue Stream for Nicox from 2024 following New Drug Application Submission for ZERVIATE in China - April 15th, 2023
- Ultimovacs ASA – Disclosure of voting rights of Annual General Meeting - April 15th, 2023
- QIAGEN showcases latest technologies to advance cancer research at AACR Annual Meeting 2023 - April 15th, 2023
- ITM lädt zu Symposium und Messestand auf der Jahrestagung der Deutschen Gesellschaft für Nuklearmedizin in Leipzig ein - April 15th, 2023
- International Carrot Day: From healthy eyesight to weight loss - 5 wonderful benefits of carrot - Zee Business - April 7th, 2023
- How the Human Eye Works | Cornea Layers/Role | Light Rays - NKCF.org - December 11th, 2022
- Eye Emergencies: Types, Symptoms, and Prevention - Healthline - November 25th, 2022
- The criteria for certification | RNIB - November 25th, 2022
- Foresight: Eye-Net Successfully Showcases its Advanced Solution to Leading OEMs and Tier One Suppliers in Japan - Marketscreener.com - November 25th, 2022
- Can you see me now? Average person begins worrying about their vision at age 39 - Study Finds - September 29th, 2022
- Contact lens wearers at higher risk of rare eye infection are you caring for your lenses the right way? - News24 - September 29th, 2022
- A man who popped a champagne cork into his eye says it felt like being poked 'times a thousand.' His vision was saved after months of treatment but it... - September 29th, 2022