When Katy Mathes and six of her family members learned they had a mutation on a BRCA gene that significantly raised their risk of breast cancer they underwent major surgery. But years later, the genetic testing company lowered the family's odds of getting the disease, Amy Dockser Marcus reports for the Wall Street Journal.
In August 2015, Mathes decided to get a BRCA test. Mathes' mother had been diagnosed with breast cancer at 49, and four of her aunts had tested positive for the BRCA gene, and "moved quickly to get surgery," Dockser Marcus reports.
Mathes and her sister, Tricia Leigh, also had positive tests. The test results showed that Mathes had up to an 84% risk of developing breast cancer by age 70 and up to a 27% risk of developing ovarian cancer by age 70. Among the general population, the odds of developing breast or ovarian cancer are 7.3% and 0.7%, respectively, Dockser Marcus reports.
But the two women grappled over the decision of whether to get surgery: Mathes wanted another child and her sister was breastfeeding her second child.
After consulting with additional doctors, Mathes eventually decided to have her ovaries and fallopian tubes removed, the same procedure her aunts, sister, and mother underwent. In addition, Mathes and her sister had double mastectomies.
"I treated my test results like the Bible," Mathes said. "There was no questioning the report."
But years after the initial test, Myriad Genetics, the molecular diagnostics company that did Mathes' test as well as her relatives', changed its classification of the BRCA variant Mathes has from "pathogenic" to "unknown significance," a move that Myriad said is very unusual.
By this point, Mathes and six of her family members had undergone surgery based on their test results. When the sisters learned the news, Mathes said, "My brain just shut off."
Susan Manley, SVP of medical services at Myriad and a board-certified genetic counselor, said, "We know these are very difficult situations. We make these reclassifications very carefully. The science is evolving." She added that changing a classification from harmful to uncertain "is a rare event, but I understand that rare is of no consolation to the patient when it happens to them."
BRCA tests are among the most common genetic tests in existence, Dockser Marcus writes, and genetic testing guidelines have expanded who should receive BRCA tests. Major genetic testing companies such as 23andMe, Ancestry, and MyHeritage now offer the tests for BRCA1 and BRCA2 genes.
However, not every lab agrees on the specific classification of a BRCA gene variant, Dockser Marcus reports. That's in part because there are "tens of thousands of BRCA variants" and not all of them necessarily carry the same level of risk for a patient, Dockser Marcus reports.
Fergus Couch, a professor at the Mayo Clinic, said some variants "have intermediate or moderate levels of risk, not full-blown risk." For a number of those variants, labs "are making a judgment call but that is not always clear to the public," Couch said.
Stephen Chanock, a geneticist at the National Cancer Institute, said, "[G]enetics is murky." He added, "It's not so simple as 'Doctor, do I have to worry or don't I have to worry?'"
According to Melissa Cline, a researcher at the University of California Santa Cruz Genomics Institute, and project manager of the BRCA Exchange, the analysis on the BRCA variant in the Mathes' family put a lot of weight on a 2011 paper that found the variant likely alters the BRCA2 protein, which can help suppress tumors.
Seth Marcus, a genetic counselor at Advocate Health Care who counseled Mathes' mother and one of her aunts, said he checked a public database to see how other labs classify the variant once he heard of Myriad's change. He said six labs still classify the variant as "likely pathogenic."
"In the end, you give the patient the data and the knowledge you know," he said.
Dockser Marcus reports that Myriad currently has 38 people in its database with the BRCA variant Mathes and her relatives have, 12 of whom come from Mathes' family. Mathes said that if she had known about the sample size, she and her husband may have asked more questions about whether surgery was appropriate.
Now, based on Mathes' family history and Myriad's classification change, Mathes' genetic counselor estimated her lifetime risk of developing breast cancer is 21%, Dockser Marcus writes.
"That is not high enough to make me remove organs," Mathes said. "I would have had another kid. I would have waited to do surgery" (Dockser Marcus, Wall Street Journal, 12/20/19).
Continue reading here:
'I would have had another kid': How an imperfect gene test led to major surgeryand big regrets - The Daily Briefing
- Genomic landscape of CCUS compared to MDS and its implications on risk prediction | Leukemia - Nature.com - May 14th, 2024
- AGBS - Postdoctoral Fellowship in Molecular Genetics of Hessian Fly Resistance in Wheat job with MOHAMMED VI ... - Times Higher Education - May 14th, 2024
- Researchers Uncover One Million New Components of the Human Genome - India Education Diary - February 18th, 2024
- Ancient retroviruses played a key role in the evolution of vertebrate brains - EurekAlert - February 18th, 2024
- New Scientific Reports publication reveals major difference in genomes of American and Chinese chestnut - EurekAlert - January 17th, 2024
- The Crucial Role of Molecular Biology in Cancer Therapy: A Comprehensive Review - Cureus - January 17th, 2024
- Cells of the future: A key to reprogramming cell identities - EurekAlert - December 22nd, 2023
- Mainz Biomed Expands Corporate Health Program for ColoAlert with the Addition of Three New Companies in Germany - Marketscreener.com - April 7th, 2023
- Molecular Genetics and Metabolism | Journal - ScienceDirect - December 11th, 2022
- People don't mate randomly but the flawed assumption that they do is an essential part of many studies linking genes to diseases and traits - The... - November 25th, 2022
- Molecular and Cell Biology and Genetics - Master of Science / PhD ... - October 7th, 2022
- NIPD Genetics: Leading Genetic Testing Company - October 7th, 2022
- Skeletal Biology and Regeneration Students Recognized For Research Excellence - UConn Today - University of Connecticut - October 7th, 2022
- Mary Munson elected fellow of the American Society for Cell Biology - UMass Medical School - October 7th, 2022
- Every Body's Talking at Them: an Interview with Jon Lieff - CounterPunch - October 7th, 2022
- TriBeta invites students to explore opportunities to work with faculty at research fair on Oct. 11 - Ohio University - October 7th, 2022
- Genetics: the Vatican Does Not Intend to Be Behind the Times - FSSPX.News - October 7th, 2022
- Yield10 Bioscience Appoints Willie Loh, Ph.D., to the Board of Directors - citybiz - October 7th, 2022
- Molecular pathways of major depressive disorder converge on the synapse | Molecular Psychiatry - Nature.com - October 7th, 2022
- Sigyn Therapeutics Strengthens Board of Directors With the Appointments of Richa Nand, Jim Dorst and Christopher Wetzel - Yahoo Finance - October 7th, 2022
- UTHSC Researcher Co-Leads Study of Genes that Modulate Aging, Lifespan - UTHSC News - UTHSC News - October 7th, 2022
- GATC Health Investor Conference to Feature First Public Demonstration of Its AI Platform's Drug Discovery Capabilities - PR Newswire - October 7th, 2022
- Three Professors Conferred Tenure and Eleven Promoted - Wesleyan Argus - October 7th, 2022
- Who will get the call from Stockholm? It's time for STAT's 2022 Nobel Prize predictions - STAT - October 7th, 2022
- Dalhousie to present exhibition celebrating Gerhard Herzberg and his legacy - Dal News - October 7th, 2022
- Why Some People Should Rethink Their Morning Cup Of Coffee - Health Digest - October 7th, 2022
- Cell and Gene Therapy: Rewriting the Future of Medicine - Technology Networks - October 7th, 2022
- UofL researchers lead the call to increase genetic diversity in immunogenomics - uoflnews.com - July 6th, 2021
- In Brief This Week: Foundation Medicine, Myriad Genetics, Genetron Health, and More - GenomeWeb - July 6th, 2021
- More filling? Tastes great? How flies, and maybe people, choose their food - Yale News - July 6th, 2021
- Genetic mapping of subsets of patients with fragile X syndro | TACG - Dove Medical Press - July 6th, 2021
- What is The Babydust Method? Danielle Lloyd swears method helped her conceive girl - The Mirror - July 6th, 2021
- Datar Cancer Genetics joins hands with US based Iylon Precision Oncology to offer personalized Precision Oncology cancer treatment solutions - PR Web - July 6th, 2021
- Mapping a pathway to competitive production - hortidaily.com - hortidaily.com - July 6th, 2021
- Associations between pancreatic expression quantitative traits and risk of pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma. - Physician's Weekly - July 6th, 2021
- Global Genomics Market | Rising Incidence of Chronic and Genetic Diseases are Key Factors to Grow Market During 2021-2029 | 23andMe, Agilent... - July 6th, 2021
- The Babydust Method Danielle Lloyd used to conceive a girl after four sons and how it works - RSVP Live - July 6th, 2021
- In the beginning science and faith - The Irish Times - June 24th, 2021
- Ancient Maya Maintained Native Tropical Forest Plants around Their Water Reservoirs | Archaeology - Sci-News.com - June 24th, 2021
- Local foundation awards $1.25 million to MIND Institute to study rare genetic condition - UC Davis Health - June 24th, 2021
- Xlife Sciences AG: Collaboration with the University of Marburg - Yahoo Finance - June 24th, 2021
- Genetics diagnostics in India is on the verge of transformation: Neeraj Gupta, Founder and CEO of Genes2me - The Financial Express - June 24th, 2021
- Precision Medicine: Improving Health With Personalized Solutions - BioSpace - June 24th, 2021
- Half of Portland areas 22 top National Merit winners hail from just 2 schools - OregonLive - June 24th, 2021
- Investing in stem cells, the building blocks of the body - MoneyWeek - June 24th, 2021
- New study finds low levels of a sugar metabolite associates with disability and neurodegeneration in multiple sclerosis - Newswise - May 14th, 2021
- Cernadas-Martn Is a Champion for Marine and Human Diversity | | SBU News - Stony Brook News - May 14th, 2021
- Four Penn Faculty: Election to the National Academy of Sciences - UPENN Almanac - May 14th, 2021
- Is there a difference between a gene-edited organism and a 'GMO'? The question has important implications for regulation - Genetic Literacy Project - May 14th, 2021
- 5 Students Inducted Into American Society for Biochemistry and Molecular Biology Honor Society - Wesleyan Connection - May 14th, 2021
- The Science of Aliens, Part 2: What Kind of Genetic Code Would Extraterrestrials Have? - Air & Space Magazine - May 14th, 2021
- UT Austin Faculty Member Receives 2021 Piper Professor Award - Office of the Executive Vice President and Provost - UT News | The University of Texas... - May 14th, 2021
- Distinguished University of Birmingham plant scientist elected to the Royal Society - University of Birmingham - May 14th, 2021
- Double Hoo Research: Undergrads and Grads Team Up to Create Knowledge - University of Virginia - May 14th, 2021
- Global Genetic Testing Market Top Countries Analysis and Manufacturers With Impact of COVID-19 | 2021-2028 Detail Analysis focusing on Application,... - May 14th, 2021
- Morag Park named to the Order of Quebec - McGill Reporter - McGill Reporter - May 14th, 2021
- Third Rock Ventures Launches Flare Therapeutics With $82 Million Series A - BioSpace - May 14th, 2021
- The Royal Society announces election of new Fellows 2021 - Cambridge Network - May 14th, 2021
- Researchers Decode the "Language" of Immune Cells - Technology Networks - May 14th, 2021
- RepliCel Launches the Next Stage of a Research Project with the University of British Columbia to Build World-Class Hair Follicle Cell Data Map -... - May 14th, 2021
- Mice Sperm Sabotage Other Swimmers With Poison | Smart News - Smithsonian Magazine - February 14th, 2021
- Study Identifies Never-Before-Seen Dual Function in Enzyme Critical for Cancer Growth - Newswise - February 14th, 2021
- Devious sperm 'poison' their rivals, forcing them to swim in circles until they die - Livescience.com - February 14th, 2021
- More needs to be done to find and fight COVID-19 variants, says Colorado researcher - FOX 31 Denver - February 14th, 2021
- Selfish sperm genes 'poison' the competition for the win - Big Think - February 14th, 2021
- Some sperm cells swim faster and even poison their competition to climb to the top - ZME Science - February 14th, 2021
- We are scientists: U of T researchers reach out to girls and women around the world - News@UofT - February 14th, 2021
- Mutations in frogs point to autism genes' shared role in neurogenesis - Spectrum - February 14th, 2021
- Global Genetic Testing Market Insights, Size Estimation, Research Insights, COVID-19 Impact and Future Trends By 2028 KSU | The Sentinel Newspaper -... - February 14th, 2021
- Acer Therapeutics Announces Topline Results from its Bioequivalence Trial of ACER-001 Compared to BUPHENYL Under Fed Conditions - GlobeNewswire - February 14th, 2021
- GeneSight Psychotropic Test's Combinatorial Approach Proves Better than Single-Gene Testing at Predicting Patient Outcomes and Medication Blood Levels... - February 14th, 2021
- Gu Ailing Eileen: I've learned to win for myself, not other people - Olympic Channel - February 14th, 2021
- Model organisms are more than just monkeys and mice - DW (English) - February 7th, 2021
- Dascena Strengthens Executive Leadership Team with Key Appointments and Promotion - Business Wire - February 7th, 2021
- PLUs Lathiena Nervo discusses her work and being named one of the 1,000 inspiring Black scientists in America - Pacific Lutheran University - February 7th, 2021
- Bioinformatics Services Market | Know the Latest Innovations and Future Market Scope - BioSpace - February 7th, 2021
- Plants May Be Able To Control the Genetics of Their Microbial Symbionts - Technology Networks - February 7th, 2021
- Risk Factor For Bacterial And Viral Co-Infection Uncovered - Forbes - February 7th, 2021
- The mistrusted medical miracle: Vaccines have revolutionized health, but some still question their safety - Charleston Gazette-Mail - February 7th, 2021
- US rushes to catch up in the race to detect mutant viruses - WWLTV.com - February 7th, 2021