Today an article entitled "Professors Critique Stem Cell Medical Tourism" appeared in the online version of The Harvard Crimson summarizing a recent panel discussion hosted in least in part by Harvard Law School assistant professor I. Glenn Cohen and University of Alberta law professor Timothy Caulfield. The article concludes thusly:
The panelists emphasized that more accurate information should be provided to the public regarding stem cell treatments.
Certainly what Cohen and Caulfield concluded is true. It has now been true for several years. We keep saying it. But are we listening to ourselves? Are we doing anything meaningful to address this? If so, is it enough?
Sadly (in my opinion, of course) the answer is 'not nearly enough'.*
For several years now, experts and organizations in the cell therapy sector have been saying that more must be done to educate and assist patients who are seeking stem cell or other cell-based treatments which do not comply with existing regulation and/or widely accepted medical or clinical research practices (hereafter called "non-compliant cell therapies").
In my opinion, attempts to address this need by the sector's professional organizations, while important, have been unnecessarily feeble, not gone nearly far enough, and legitimately appear by many to be high-minded and pedantic.
Almost all efforts to-date to address this issue by ISSCR, CIRM, ISCT and others including authors such as Caufield - as laudable and needed as they are - have been focused on helping distinguish between compliant and non-compliant treatments (and providers). This is certainly much needed. But what is left, I submit, is an even greater unmet need.
What almost all efforts to-date have failed to recognize or address is that where real help is needed is in helping patients distinguish between the many shades of grey among non-compliant treatments (and providers).
Emerging organizations like ICMS (now in partnership with AABB) have recognized and attempted to address this unmet need through a commitment to create some level of certification, accreditation or standardization of clinics participating in this business of selling non-compliant cell therapies.
While their intentions appear on-target as one meaningful way to address this unmet need and certainly their willingness to tackle this issue in a bold way is to be lauded, the ICMS is inexperienced and underfunded. I remain hopeful that now through their new partnership with AABB they will be able to provide something that really addresses this unmet need but the jury remains out on whether they will succeed.
Anyone who has followed this blog and/or my threads on LinkedIn know I have been thinking about and discussing this issue for some time. In a desire to move to very concrete suggestions, I want to recommend the following 6 steps to my industry colleagues and professional organizations:
1. 50 shades of grey. Let's admit that this issue is not black-and-white but, as is almost always, involves a broad spectrum of grey in the middle.
In addition to helping patients distinguish between compliant and non-compliant treatments (and providers) there are a lot of ways to help patients distinguish between non-compliant cell therapy treatments (and providers) which are more or less risky.
In addition to helping patients distinguish between compliant and non-compliant treatments (and providers) there are a lot of ways to help patients distinguish between non-compliant cell therapy treatments (and providers) which are more or less risky.
Let me use examples.
On the one end of the non-compliant spectrum I would put forward a clinical like Okyanos Heart Institute which (as I understand it) intends to provide cell therapy treatments in the Bahamas to US patients using the Cytori system for cardiac conditions as soon as such treatments are perfectly legal and available to European patients but years before such treatments will be available in the US.
Non-compliant? Yes. But certainly no evidence I'm aware of to support a belief that seeking treatment from them would be any more risky than travelling to Europe to receive the same treatment in a manner perfectly compliant with European regulations.
On the other end of the spectrum are the kinds of clinics highlighted recently by 60 minutes or which are the subject of ongoing lawsuits.
In between - in my opinion - are clinics like Stem Cell Institute and StemCellMD.
2. Step out of the ivory tower. Let's recognize that in certain circumstances patients are going to go pay for non-compliant cell therapies and we must do more to help these patients than simply shake our finger and tell them they mustn't.
For some, helping patients distinguish between the better and worst non-compliant clinics might involve a fair amount of nose-pinching but this is the equivalent of the methadone clinic for heroine addicts. By supporting the better of two evils we are not endorsing it as 'good', we are simply recognizing it is better.
This is a recognition that we cannot just abandon people because they made (or are going to make) decisions with which we ultimately disapprove. It is a recognition that sometimes the most righteous thing to do is not only to help people do what we would ideally want them to do but to help them do the best they can in their circumstances and on their terms - even terms with which we may ultimately disagree.
3. A risk-based strategy. Let's recognize that even the FDA triages their response to non-compliance and we would do well to do the same. As a regulated industry we are perfectly comfortable with risk-based assessments and it should be applied here.
Rather than treating all non-compliance as equally evil, let's apply some risk-based analysis to the situation and develop a strategy to root out the worst (highest-risk) offenders.
4. This is not just about tourism anymore - the problem has come home to roost. Let's recognize that this is no longer just a problem of patients leaving a regulated jurisdiction seeking a non-compliant treatment in a jurisdiction with no or more permissive regulation.
Non-compliant treatments are growing rapidly even in the most highly regulated jurisdictions. No where is this more true than in the United States.
5. Take responsibility. Let's recognize that we cannot expect our regulatory enforcement agencies to do it all. They are under-staffed and under-funded. They - and the people we all serve - need our active participation in dealing with offenders and those risking patient safety.
From a self-interested perspective, we owe it to our industry to help crack down on those who put the credibility and legitimacy of cell therapies at highest risk.
6. Let's grow a pair and call a spade a spade. If a non-compliant clinic is providing treatments that we believe represent a high-risk to patient safety and the industry's credibility, let's have the b*lls to call them on it. They can't sue everyone.
ISSCR backed down on their stem cell tourism initiative after being threatened by lawsuits. Who has stepped up in their absence? Individual bloggers and authors like Paul Knoeplfer, Alexey Bresenev, Leigh Turner, and myself all who have been threatened with litigation several times for having the audacity to call certain non-compliant clinics out for what we deem - in our own risk-based analysis - to be the worst offenders.
By way of example, several of my colleagues have recently committed to doing all they can do to call out David Steenblock and his non-compliant cell therapy treatments, many of which are provided at his clinic in California for a plethora of conditions. In their opinion, many of his treatments represent some of worst examples of non-compliance in the United States right now. There are many faces or fronts to his practice including http://www.davidsteenblock.com, http://www.stemcellmd.org, http://www.strokedoctor.com, http://www.davidsteenblock.net, etc.
If, as an industry, we act with more cohesion (collaboratively applying a risk-based assessment of non-compliant clinics) and speak with a more cohesive voice in terms of calling out those clinics and treatments which we conclude pose the greatest risk based on an objective set of criterion, this will present a multi-pronged, formidable and existential threat to clinics that they can't ignore or threaten away.
___
I will be taking these 6 recommendations to any organization who will listen. I hope you will consider doing the same.
In the meantime - as always - I welcome your comments.
___
* This is my opinion not necessarily the opinion of any clients I represent or organizations I serve. Judge me - not them - accordingly.
Related Post
- Slowing ALS Progression Through Gene Therapy - Forbes - May 5th, 2024
- Enhancing IVF Outcomes: The Role Of Advanced Technologies In Regenerative Medicine | TheHealthSite.com - TheHealthSite - May 5th, 2024
- Stanford stem cell researcher who discovered how to regrow cartilage, dies at 48 - Redwood City Pulse - May 5th, 2024
- Taysha Gene Therapies Announces Regenerative Medicine Advanced Therapy (RMAT) Designation Granted by U.S. ... - GlobeNewswire - May 5th, 2024
- Molecular discovery has potential to solve the billion-dollar global cost of poorly managed wound healing - Medical Xpress - March 29th, 2024
- Science Saturday: A year of new directions and advancements for ... - March 29th, 2024
- Diverse ways regenerative medicine is advancing health care - March 29th, 2024
- Exosomes and Stem Cells Are the Future of Anti-Aging - NewBeauty Magazine - March 29th, 2024
- Global Organoids and Spheroids Market Set for Remarkable Growth, Reaching USD 7.70 Billion by 2034 with a CAGR ... - GlobeNewswire - March 29th, 2024
- Growth Projections for the Regenerative Medicine Market - BioProcess Insider - March 10th, 2024
- Regenerative Medicine - Cell Therapies - BioProcess Insider - March 10th, 2024
- Transitioning from traditional surgical methods to the innovative use of stem cells - pharmaphorum - March 10th, 2024
- Stem cell-based regenerative medicine - PMC - National Center for ... - February 27th, 2024
- Unlocking the Mysteries of the Hippo Pathway: A Leap Towards Conquering Cancer and Regenerating Tissues - Medriva - February 27th, 2024
- PRISM MarketView Spotlights BioStem Technologies in the Expanding Wound Care Market - Yahoo Finance - February 27th, 2024
- Therapeutic Solutions International Files Patent on "Facilitating Effects" of JadiCells on Gene Therapy Mediated Cell ... - Yahoo Finance - February 27th, 2024
- RION Expands Manufacturing Operations with Cutting-Edge Facility in Rochester, Minnesota - Yahoo Finance - February 27th, 2024
- Hands-On Solutions: Applying Prosthetic Sensory Technology In Rehabilitation - Forbes - February 27th, 2024
- UC Irvine Embarks on a Transformative Journey in Stem Cell Research with a $4 Million Boost - BNN Breaking - February 27th, 2024
- Less Surgery, More Recovery: Here is How Regenerative Medicine is Shaping the Future for Neurosurgeons - News Channel Nebraska - February 27th, 2024
- SPONSORED: Regen Rx Offers Both Non-Invasive Regenerative Medicine Procedures and Ultrasound-Guided ... - exploreClarion.com - February 27th, 2024
- ROSM Celebrates 10 Years of Advancing Patient Care Through Regenerative Medicine - goskagit.com - February 27th, 2024
- Expanding the Horizons of Cell and Gene Therapy - RegMedNet - February 27th, 2024
- Regenerative medicine | NIST - February 10th, 2024
- Home - Kansas Regenerative Medicine - February 10th, 2024
- Translational Regenerative Medicine market is estimated to grow at a CAGR of 24.3% by 2034: Visiongain - Yahoo Finance - February 10th, 2024
- Cellular senescence is associated with osteonecrosis of the femoral head while mesenchymal stem cell conditioned ... - Nature.com - February 10th, 2024
- Top 3 grants in regenerative medicine: January 2024 - RegMedNet - February 10th, 2024
- Organogenesis Holdings Inc. to Report Fourth Quarter and Fiscal Year 2023 Financial Results on February 29, 2024 - Yahoo Finance - February 10th, 2024
- Unlocking the power of stem cell therapy - Drug Target Review - February 10th, 2024
- Innovative stem cell therapy could be "game changer" in epilepsy - The Pharma Letter - February 10th, 2024
- Neurona lands $120m to advance regenerative cell therapy pipeline - Longevity.Technology - February 10th, 2024
- Neurona Therapeutics Raises $120M to Advance Groundbreaking Pipeline of Regenerative Cell Therapy Candidates ... - GlobeNewswire - February 10th, 2024
- Treating Joint Problems in the Modern Age: How Regenerative Medicine Paves the Way - Health shots - February 10th, 2024
- Cancer-related mutations appear in stem cell derivatives used in regenerative medicine, shows study - Phys.org - January 17th, 2024
- Researchers genetically modify stem cells to evade immunological rejection - University of Arizona - January 17th, 2024
- The Impact and Implications of Regenerative Medicine in Urology - Cureus - January 17th, 2024
- LVHN announces opening of new stem cell transplant center. Here's what that means for the Lehigh Valley - The Morning Call - January 17th, 2024
- Clinical applications of stem cell-derived exosomes | Signal Transduction and Targeted Therapy - Nature.com - January 17th, 2024
- Therapeutic Solutions International Launches Adult Stem Cell Therapy Company Focused on Curing Epilepsy - Business Wire - January 17th, 2024
- Cell Therapy Technologies Market Projected to Reach Valuation of USD 47.3 Billion at 24.7% CAGR from 2024-2033 ... - GlobeNewswire - January 17th, 2024
- Cancer Mutations in 22% of Stem Cells: Concern for Regenerative Medicine - BNN Breaking - January 17th, 2024
- San Jose blood stem cell donor meets 15-year-old whose life he saved in Los Angeles - The Mercury News - May 17th, 2023
- Regenerative medicine: Current therapies and future directions - April 23rd, 2023
- What Is Regenerative Medicine? | Goals and Applications | ISCRM - April 23rd, 2023
- Important Patient and Consumer Information About Regenerative Medicine ... - April 23rd, 2023
- Regenerative medicine can be a boon for those with Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis - Hindustan Times - April 23rd, 2023
- About Regenerative Medicine - Center for Regenerative ... - Mayo Clinic - April 7th, 2023
- Regenerative Medicine | National Institutes of Health (NIH) - April 7th, 2023
- Porcine Vaccine Market is estimated to be US$ 4.41 billion by 2030 with a CAGR of 7.50%during the forecast - EIN News - April 7th, 2023
- Advancing Safe and Effective Regenerative Medicine Products - March 21st, 2023
- Active Wound Care Market Rising demand for Skin Substitutes to boost the industry (2023-2033) | CAGR of 5.5% - EIN News - March 21st, 2023
- Veterinary Orthopedic Implants Market is estimated to be 421.3 Million by 2029 with a CAGR of 5.3% - By PMI - EIN News - March 21st, 2023
- ASKA Pharmaceutical : February 7 2023 EME and ASKA Announce Collaboration Agreement on Creating Novel PharmaLogical VHH to address an unmet medical... - February 8th, 2023
- A Look At Some Of The Companies Innovating In the Cutting-Edge Regenerative Medicine Field - Yahoo Finance - October 15th, 2022
- The Switch to Regenerative Medicine - Dermatology Times - October 15th, 2022
- The Alliance for Regenerative Medicine Announces Election of 2023 Officers, Executive Committee, and Board of Directors - GlobeNewswire - October 15th, 2022
- Mathematical model could bring us closer to effective stem cell therapies - Michigan Medicine - October 15th, 2022
- 'We have to find a way': FDA seeks solutions to aid bespoke gene therapy - BioPharma Dive - October 15th, 2022
- American Academy of Stem Cell Physicians to Offer Licensed Physicians Board Examination in Regenerative Medicine - GlobeNewswire - October 15th, 2022
- Discover Medical Advances in Cellular Therapy Research Using Cord Blood for Cancer, HIV, Cerebral Palsy and Autism During World Cord Blood Day 2022 -... - October 15th, 2022
- The Risk-Reward Proposition for CGT Clinical Trials - Applied Clinical Trials Online - October 15th, 2022
- Cell therapy weekly: Ray Therapeutics and Forge Biologics expand partnership - RegMedNet - October 15th, 2022
- FDA Expands Oversight of Cell and Gene Therapies - Pharmaceutical Technology Magazine - October 15th, 2022
- Frequency Therapeutics Completes Enrollment of Phase 2b Study of FX-322 for the Treatment of Sensorineural Hearing Loss - Business Wire - October 15th, 2022
- The Health Benefits Of Sea Moss, According To Experts - Forbes - October 15th, 2022
- ProKidney Announces Multiple Abstracts Selected for Presentation at the American Society of ... - The Bakersfield Californian - October 15th, 2022
- Pain Management & Regenerative Medicine Specialists DFW - September 4th, 2022
- Tissue Engineering and Regenerative Medicine - National Institute of ... - September 4th, 2022
- First U.S. patient receives autologous stem cell therapy to treat dry AMD - National Institutes of Health (.gov) - September 4th, 2022
- International Stem Cell and Regenerative Medicine Research and Therapeutic Center in Egypt - Construction Review - September 4th, 2022
- Regenerative Medicine Market to Garner Bursting Revenues [+USD 27.29 Billion] with Top Growing Companies During 2022-2029 - eTurboNews | eTN - September 4th, 2022
- Immusoft Takes First-Ever Engineered B Cell Therapy into Clinic - BioSpace - September 4th, 2022
- Addressing Diversity Barriers to Regenerative Medicine Free Press of Jacksonville - Jacksonville Free Press - September 4th, 2022
- TikoMed's ILB mobilizes and modulates key growth factors that trigger a cascade of neuroprotective mechanisms able to target all... - September 4th, 2022
- Frequency Therapeutics to Participate in September Investor and Medical Conferences - Business Wire - September 4th, 2022
- Can the immortal jellyfish teach us how to reverse aging? - Earth.com - September 4th, 2022
- Applied StemCell Announces the Expansion of its cGMP Manufacturing Facility to Support Cell and Gene Therapy - Business Wire - September 4th, 2022
- Omega Therapeutics Announces Appointment of Rainer Boehm to its Board of Directors - PR Newswire - September 4th, 2022
- Rise In Number Of CROS In Various Regions Such As Europe Is Expected To Fuel The Growth Of Induced Pluripotent Stem Cell Market At An Impressive CAGR... - September 4th, 2022